As Princess Celestia was preparing to return to Canterlot with Philomena, Twilight Sparkle approached her. "Princess Celestia?"
"Yes, Twilight?"
Twilight tilted her head. "Just how long have you had a pet phoenix? Because this is the first time I've ever seen Philomena."
Celestia smiled. "Oh, I've had her for a while," she said. "Though to be honest, I frequently don't see her for years at a time. It isn't healthy for either the pet or the owner if a phoenix is kept cooped up like an ordinary bird. Philomena just came back to Canterlot two moons ago."
"How long was she gone?" Twilight asked.
"About twenty, maybe twenty-five years?" Celestia shrugged. "Her favorite hunting ground is past the Griffon Kingdom. She usually nests for a good ten or fifteen years whenever she goes there."
"Oh." Twilight fell silent. "So, umm...if you knew she was about to, err, burn, why did you bring her to tea? I mean, she looked awful."
"Well, it's so rare I get to show off Philomena," Celestia said. "I really wanted to show her to Fluttershy since I know she loves animals, and, well..." She looked sheepish. "After all your letters about her..." She shook her head. "Fluttershy has tamed manticores, a full-grown dragon, and even a cockatrice. I guess I just assumed she knew enough about magical creatures that she'd recognize a phoenix when she saw one. That...was my mistake." Her eyes twinkled. "I do occasionally make them."
Philomena let out a shrill, piercing cry. "Oh! I suppose we'd best be off," Celestia said. "I do, after all, have to prepare for the sunset. Goodbye, my faithful student."
"Goodbye, Princess," Twilight said. She looked to the phoenix. "And goodbye to you too, Philomena."
Huh. That's certainly interesting.
I don't think I've heard of phoenixes being away from their owners before in other stories. It would explain why we haven't seen Philomena since then, and why Spike had to return Peewee to his parents.
7255754 Headcanon accepted.
This would certainly explain why Twilight didn't know that Celestia had a pet Phoenix.
This...makes so much sense... Mind blown.
"How long have you had a brother?" replied Celestia.
I'm finally starting to get to this. It seems interesting so I'll read more later.
Hmm... I like it!
ANOTHER!
You know, the end part of this chapter - when Celestia admits she makes mistakes - takes on all new overtones given the ending of the one that's now before it.