• Member Since 3rd Aug, 2011
  • offline last seen Nov 30th, 2023

Wheller


Surprise!

T

After discovering a strange object from long ago, Twilight Sparkle and her friends embark on an expedition to a place that time forgot, hoping to discover the secrets it's been hiding for over a thousand years.

Chapters (8)
Comments ( 56 )

WHAT THE FUCK SURPRISE? :raritydespair:

And before anyone else says it. The dynamite that they were using was stuff that Pinkie Pie made in her basement.

So, is Surprise still Made Of Iron or is AJ going to come home to them having a wake for somepony she barely knows and doesn't like? Also, is Octavia going to be an annoying, stuck-up jerk all the way to Ponyville?

40096

Applejack doesn't know Surprise at all actually.

Surprise on the otherhoof, knows (knew?) Applejack very well.:pinkiecrazy:

Surprise nooooo!!!! I was just starting to half like her in a weird sorta way. From earlier Octavia I'm assuming she will be way too serious (though rightly so) then be a huge jerk all the way there till she brightens up to the group. Either way, I want the Doctor!

THE PLOT THICKENS

and Octavia's patience thins :rainbowlaugh:

40689

I'd forgotten that she didn't have HER memories of the past world restored and, well, that she didn't stick around to listen to what anypony had to say. SHE spent most of her time in Old Appleloosa getting hammered on cheap booze and bitching about Nephites.

As for Surprise, she has a lot of 'fond' memories of AJ, doesn't she?

40927
As does my like of her....she's quickly becoming a flat character.

Octavia has a concerning way of telling somepony they're happy they're alive. :coolphoto:

So.....when does she ask Twilight for help with her lack-of-literacy problem? Also, will Vinyl get off on getting pummeled by Mean Bowtie Lady or what?

She do have a point, saying that you got about a month to live and then just leave get cured and not mention it is not really such a nice thing to do to someone.

Oh god no, I forgot about 'Tavi, poor Vynl. Scratch does deserve it though she never stopped to write a letter saying "Oh hey I'm not fucking dead:rainbowderp:"? I'm still wondering when our Time Lord assistant Colgate will arrive!

41439
Maybe Zecora can show up and help Tavi smack her around some more; they do seem to have the need to kick her plot in common.

And now we wait for Vinyl to screw up this relationship :twilightsmile:
Its the circle of life, because in these stories, Murphy's law is the law.

And now we also need to learn exactly why it is that Celestia is such a violent Luddite idiot; for someone who purportedly loves her little ponies, she sure wants to doom them to be as ignorant and fearful (or as ready to make a false god of her) as the imbeciles in New Appleloosa.

42184
It's not just the Vinyl/Octavia relationship that's doomed; I can readily see something bad happening to Caramel and Carrot Top. What that thing is is up to the author but it will be painful.

What is Emerald up to? She must have been working on something for a very long time, and just saying sorry but I don't need you anymore to a goddess... I think something big is about to go down and it will have something to do with whatever project she clearly must be working on.

Why does this pleasant pair of anecdotes make the phrase 'calm before the storm' echo through my brain?

43511

Well, actually, ever since writing Bridge over River Rijn, I've discovered I don't really like having everything blow up horribly ever five seconds any more.

So from now on, it'll be every ten seconds. :pinkiehappy:

Finally, I have been refreshing your profile page every half hour or so since I came home.

43515

Glad to hear that lol, it got a bit boring/annoying that after one disaster they get another one right away.


At the start of the chapter i was concerned Fluttershy would turn into a killer again, now im concerned she will turn into a sex crazes maniac, and that rarity gave her roofies in her drink too... :raritywink:

This a disconcerting twist! Drat Flootershu is setting herself up for disaster and it is fantastic. I'm glad to hear that it won't be a horrid mess every five seconds it was fun but ugh getting a tad much in a short time.

well, thats a relief. i though you had dropped off the radar a bit when i signed in, but then i remembered i didnt start tracking this one.

and nothings gonna blow up every 5 seconds now? are you sure....:trixieshiftright:

Well, I'd expected some level of nastiness to appear; I just didn't expect it to take the form of Octavia being an undercover police constable. That being said, the cliffhanger has pushed that worry aside because I need to know what the Machine Cult is and why it might explain the extreme antipathy to technology that defines Celestia.

43875
I've done that too, wondering to myself, "hmm, wheller's been awfully quiet lately...", and then checking his stories and realizing there's a fully complete one I haven't even touched yet, heh.

Da fuk, when Trigger died they surely wanted some heads to roll still, so they could have taken Vinyl, Octy probably knew where her stash of drugs was and all,so what better then to arrest a celebrity lol.
Could show that O did care for Vinyl.

And lol , machine cult = want to build a nuke.
if its that its to obvious lol (i mean 2 were already used, 3rd time is the charm? )

I keep getting these mixed messages around Monty in my head... Is he good? bad?

44563 He just is. I'm fairly sure he tends to fall on the "good" side, but he mostly does stuff for himself.

44595

Exactly, good and evil are relative. Monty isn't one or the other. And neither is Twilight, or Vinyl, or Rainbow.

'Sees title, turns on pip-biy, puts on tunnel snake's jacket' :pinkiecrazy:

44823 you misspelled pipboy you FOOL

I...what? What just happened? I get that Octavia might have been an undercover detective all along, but I don't really understand the sudden emotional rift that just exploded between her and Vinyl. Octavia seemed genuinely attached to Vinyl in the previous chapters/stories, and vice versa. Now they hate each other? What happened to all the emotional connection from before? Unless there's something I'm missing here, this sudden shift just doesn't seem that believable.

Anyhow, yay for Sergeant Lucky and Constable Crème being alive again XD.

45178

Octavia has a pretty bad temper, and to be fair, so does Vinyl. Particularly when you hit where it hurts. Her alcoholism and prior drug use. Fights like this would not be uncommon for them, though the topic in question is hardly ever of this magnitude.

House shopping one second, at eachother's throats the next?

SUCH IS THE CYCLE OF VINYL SCRATCH'S LOVELIFE
I mean hot damn that was fast :twilightoops:
I wanna say Octavia might apologize later on but given how things have gone before I wouldnt count on it :trixieshiftleft:

Machine Cult? Oh my Brotherhood reference (I think don't quote me on that) Montana no matte how neutral-ish he seems has been kinda helpful I guess, but I really don't care what caught my attention was Octavia calling Scratch a Drug addled whore. That is really hitting where it hurts so I can see one/both losing their temper there.

Wasn't Vinyl's excessive drug abuse, etc. part of the old world? Since Octavia's old-world memories haven't been restored, does that mean that old-world Vinyl and new world Vinyl effectively lived the same lives?

46567

Vinyl Scratch is plagued with poor judgement and and even worse impulse control. They're not exactly the same, but similar enough that Vinyl has trouble sorting the difference between memories from the two worlds.

There seems to be another thing she's not good at: understanding the ponies around her. She has no real idea that it wasn't JUST a job for DI Auditore and doesn't honestly seem to care.

46609

Vinyl is mad, Octavia is mad, Surpise is mad (different context though, I suppose.)

EVERYPONY IS MAD! :pinkiehappy:

Octavia and Vinyl fight all the time. They'll come around, they always do.

46614
Ah. Good point. It is the one constant in both worlds gone mad. Well, that and the fact that electronic devices bring out the fearful maniac in Celestia.

Great work Vinyl, why get help to do something when you can go alone and die right? :facehoof:

Well she always got lucky breaks before who says she won't get one again :raritywink:

Well almost always except for the whole everything that happened before this like radiation poisoning legion coming out, the whole old world really, and about a dozen things I can't really remember exactly.

and so another another adventure begins....again.

Watch these guys be so nuts that Celestia's fear of technology has a superficial justification.

Always count on Surprise :pinkiehappy:

Surprise ftw

I don't care if surprise molested poor Twi or that she is a murderous psychopath with a tendency to butcher things with a chain knife, I am impressed with the helpfulness she is showing!

I actually didn't happen to notice the bit about Surprise mimicking the actions and emotions of the ponies around her. It makes a lot of sense now, and it's a pretty cool concept too.

Anyway, perhaps Surprise's reflection of Vinyl's personality would allow her to remember the pony she really is, before she gets even more pissed off. Despite not exactly having much of her own personality now that this has been explained to the readers, I still like Surprise, possibly as the best character in this fic. Awesome stuff.

Login or register to comment