• Member Since 30th Jan, 2014
  • offline last seen 6 hours ago

scifipony


Published Science Fiction Author and MLP G4 fanfiction writer. Like my work? Buy me a cuppa joe or visit my patreon!

E

When Rainbow Dash rockets off to find Spitfire, planning to surf the jet stream to cross half the length of Equestria in just hours, she has no idea she will need to work with an "old friend" to do so.

Chapters (1)
Comments ( 4 )

Failure was not an option..

Extra period.

…and quickly rocketed into the blue sun drenched skies above them.

There should probably be a comma after ‘blue’ and a hyphen between ‘sun’ and ‘drenched’.

Soon I could see the weather front, a long line of clouds stretching for miles to the left of clear weather to the right.

This reads a bit oddly. Perhaps if that ‘of’ was a ‘with’ instead?

Unfortunately, he talked to another recruit, a lavender mare.

Another odd read. My first impulse is to say it should be ‘was talking’, but I guess it could work as-is in certain dialects.

He wrote a note on a pad and ripped the sheet loose..

Another extra period.

Lightning dust demonstrated her whistle.

Missing a capital.

As Twilight had noticed, I had eagle eyes and noticed everything below me. I now few just a hundred feet above the trees. Perhaps that was why I didn't notice Spitfire until she was shouting at me from above.

Two things: First, ‘few’ should be ‘flew’. Second, notice that the word ‘notice’ is used three times in this short paragraph. It can be grating for the same word to appear too often or too close together. This is where synonyms come in handy.

…where I spotted a carpet of blue crocus and in a sea of red witch hazel;

This is another funky read, specifically the combination of ‘and’ and ‘in’. One of them would seem to work better, rather than both.

Keeps muttering about Iris and Papryus and Gyrus.

Do you mean Papyrus?

Zecora's appearance was rather unexpected, but I guess I'll roll with it. It seems more like a role for a nameless background character, really.

Even Cadence's Bullet Express…
I wasn't surprised that Princess Cadence herself…
"Princess Cadence. I'm Spitfire."
Cadence looked to me.
Cadence blinked a few times and tilted her head.

It is generally agreed that her name is spelled Cadance, even though the musical term is spelled as you put it.

Celestia had already pinned me to the wall, like a bug, when she'd overheard me confess to Scootaloo what I'd done.

I have two nitpicks with this sentence: First, why was Celestia around while Rainbow Dash was hanging with Scootaloo? It seems a bit odd. Third Second, I would think Twilight would have told Celestia about that long before she could have found out on her own. The world is a character; its situations are in-character when they keep to the norm of the world (Celestia only visits for important matters; Twilight keeps Celestia informed.), and out of character when they deviate from it without explanation.
Pre-posting edit: It seems you have a previous story that may address this. I'll take a look.

Cadence blinked a few times and tilted her head. "Isn't that at six o'clock?"

Although living in Canterlot Castle for a while might well make her familiar with such things, it still strikes me as a bit odd that Cadance would know what hour the event is when she isn't attending, or even nearby.

In all, I like how you addressed the problem of getting Spitfire back so fast, and I like the idea of Lightning Dust's career turn. But Zecora out of nowhere, when it could have been any old pony, felt a bit weird; as did bringing in Cadance when she doesn't seem to add anything. Using important characters for minor roles can be a little awkward. You could say they're overqualified.

6473133
Thanks for the critique. Will fix it after I finish my long plane ride. Good points in oversights and story choices!

6473133

Well, well, well. Thank you for that critique. It was both insightful and inciting. As a novelist by avocation, I'm new to this speed-writing and speed-proofing thing. I'd certainly like to bottle you up and have you available on occasion! (I'm certain my agent would want me to, in any case.)

I enjoyed this. It's fun to imagine what happened off-screen in episodes. Showing that Lightning grew is good too. The one problem I have is lack of conflict. I was never really scared for the characters, and they all get along and work together a bit too well. I was expecting some sort of conflict between Rainbow and Lightning. The bit with Zecora at the end might have been superfluous too.

Other than that, I enjoyed reading a first person Rainbow Dash story. We rarely get to see her perspective this closely in fanfiction. As someone who really enjoys writing her, I had fun with the little introspective bits you put in.

Login or register to comment