After coming back and having another fuck with Luna, I had the last slice of pizza from my fridge and another ice cold Leinenkugel. One could consider it stupid to drink beer so early in the morning, but fuck it, I’m literally having sex with small horses all day (and possibly longer depending on how many I have to bone before I make it to the center).
I felt slightly dizzy and lightweight, so I was bound to do something either wild and out of character or totally stupid that could leave me stuck here until the end of time. I went to the board and tossed those dice. Eight. The piece moved.
Wonder who’s next.
The text appeared:
When you have a preference, its hard to compare. What do you like more, a stallion or a mare?
Another power stone maybe?
As predicted, a red-and-blue-colored stone flew from and floated over the gem. I picked it up.
“Let me guess,” I said loud enough that I hoped Luna could hear, “this stone will allow me to change the gender of a pony that I choose.”
“Good guess,” answered Luna.
Whatever. This one’s for reals.
I rolled the dice again. Six. The piece moved again, followed by more text:
If you’re looking for a great lay, then with Lyra Heartstrings you’ll want to play.
I was thrown back into Equestria.
I woke up inside a little house, lying on the couch. The familiar green unicorn came downstairs to find me.
“Oh my,” she said. “It’s finally my turn.”
That’s weird. I thought she would be ecstatic to see me; me being a human and all.
“You you’d never believe it, but I’ve never gotten any action at all in this game. I guess no ones ever gotten this far.” She gasped as if she realized something. “You must be really talented to get here. I bet you’re going to be great.” She crawled up to me on the couch and ripped my boxers away.
“Oh, big boy.” She began slowly giving small licks at my penis, progressively arousing it to the point of full stiffness. Once my cock was fully erect, she slowly enveloped her mouth over it. I was very surprised by her. Despite the size of my dick, she was able to shove a lot in there. With my passion kicking in, I grabbed Lyra’s horn and began to stroke it up and down. She stopped after feeling a wave of pressure herself.
“What was that?” she asked, surprised.
“What? I was just stroking your horn.”
“That was the most incredible thing I’ve ever felt. What are those things on your hooves?”
“Hooves? These are my hands, and these little things are called fingers. Shouldn’t you know that? I mean, you’re a human expert or something, aren’t you?”
“I’ve never even heard of a human until just now…” she suddenly started blushing and talking in a much more hushed tone, “…but whatever you are, I want those soft flexible hands all around me.”
Feeling this was for the best, I began massaging Lyra’s body all over, stroking her fur with the palms of my hand and pressing into her body with my fingers. Lyra had never felt such a sensation like this before and she was certainly enjoying it. It was almost difficult to rub her, as she squirmed too much for me to get a good rhythm. It was apparent though that I didn’t need it, as she was perfectly fine with what I was doing.
“You liked that, huh?” I asked. “Wait until you get a load of this!”
I stuck my thumb into her vagina. Causing her to scream in ecstasy.
“Yes!” she cried. “Don’t stop!”
I then inserted my index finger into her anus. I began massaging the insides of her anus and pussy with my fingers. She felt so lax on the couch that when I touched her, her muscles jiggled like gelatin. If that wasn’t enough of an indication, her eyes were closed and her tongue hung out the side of her mouth. I knew that this was what she wants and what she would have wanted had she been the human lover that she was.
As I continued to probe her, I felt a squeeze on my fingers. She moaned, louder and louder until she finally orgasmed all over her couch.
She mast have been out for what seemed like a half hour, so I stroked her as she laid next to me. Finally, she came to.
“Oh my,” she exclaimed. “That was the most pleasure I’ve ever felt. I may never go back to stallions again.”
“What about Bon-Bon?” I asked.
“Bon-Bon? Wha- Me and her? No no no, we’re just friends. What made you even think that?”
“What’s the fandom?”
I explained to her the popularity of My Little Pony in my world and how Lyra is portrayed as a fanatic of humans and may have a thing with the pony Bon-Bon.
“That’s just crazy. I’m straight as a die.”
“Because now it’s your turn to love me.”
I moved in for a kiss, catching Lyra by surprise. She then began kissing me as I laid her on her back. I continued kissing her as I stroked her hair with my fingers, a feeling which she also enjoyed.
Once I got her into a state of comfort, I shifted my way down to her vagina. My face was right in front of the succulent slit when I pressed my face on and slipped my tongue in. I lapped up any juices that were left over from her first cum and licked her walls for her own pleasure. Lyra arched her stomach up as I moved around inside her, moaning all the while.
Knowing that I had to cum for the turn to be complete, I took my face out and shifted my body back up. My erect penis was on line with her sex as I moved up. She assumed that I was going in for another kiss, but as my dick slid into her moist vagina, her eyes widened and she bit her lip, trying to contain herself.
When I felt the entirety of my dick slide in, I began shoving in and out, eliciting screams of ecstasy from the green unicorn. That’s when I did something that I knew would bring her over the edge. I reached over and grabbed her horn and began stroking it up and down again.
I felt the magical electricity run through my body like it did with Twilight, and she was clearly enjoying it too. She moaned even louder than before, the pleasure causing her vagina to grip my penis and pull me in and out harder and harder.
Lyra came again, filling her caverns with her juices and sending a jolt of magical energy from my hand all over my body. The wave of electricity made its way to my penis, supercharging it with an intense pleasure. The feeling of her juices and the energy running through my cock caused me to shoot a load right into Lyra. The semen must have hit something sensitive, as Lyra squeezed every muscle in her body, including the one that was around my penis. Thankfully she let go soon enough that I could finish my ejaculation. Feeling tired from our lay, we cuddled up with each other on the couch.
Once I felt rested, I got up to Lyra’s pantry for a glass of water. I felt Lyra shift on the couch, signaling that she was awake.
“Remember when I said that I may never go back to stallions? I revoke that statement. I will never go back to stallions after that.”
I put the emptied glass on her counter and sat down beside her.
“You shouldn’t say that,” I told her. “I may not win this game and never see you again. If you’re going to restrict yourself from sex like that, you’re going to be a mess when you’re in heat. If it’s any consolation, just imagine my fingers caressing you as you’re being rutted by a stallion. ‘K?”
Lyra spread her legs out revealing her vagina again. I stuck my face in and was sucked in, bringing me back to my house.