Reset Password
Resend Verification Email
5
0
20
Joined September 2011
Groups
-
48w, 2dAuthor Support
-
45w, 5dTwilight's Library
-
40w, 6dThe Usual
-
32w, 3dfimfiction's favorites
- Show All Groups
-
41w, 1dShining Armor and Cadence
-
8w, 5dchangelings need love to
-
25w, 2dMLP: Motherhood is Magical
-
10w, 3dVallett's Private Library
865
11,592
Along came Rainbow Dash.
“Afternoon Dinky Hooves, Berry Pinch,” Pipsqueak greeted as he came around the Police House front desk. “The usual?” He turned to the greyish-rose filly.
“Yeah,” Berry Pinch answered the young colt. “I’ve got to collect my mom so she can watch the store while we visit Noi’s.” She let her pink mane flop over her face as she sat on her haunches. “This happens every weekend,” she let out a long suffering sigh. “Can’t you ask your mom to not catch mine so often?”
“I tried.” He answered. “But when my mom Cherry Top catches wind of something out of place, she gets this little pony whispering into her ear and just has to investigate. Your mom passed out on a park bench attracts mine like a fly to stale cider. She really shouldn’t be drinking so much.”
“That’s like a kettle calling a pot black,” Berry Pinch replied hotly. “Your other mom, Blue Copper buys more Wild Pegasus whiskey than any pony in town.”
Dinky Hooves interrupted, knowing where this conversation was going. It was a sore and shared bond between the two. “The sooner we pick up Pinch’s mom, the sooner we can get going.”
“Right,” Pipsqueak answered the pale violet Unicorn filly. “Mom!” he called out as loudly as he could.
“In the pantry dear,” he heard his mom Cherry Top reply.
“I’m taking the key to let Ms Berry Punch out of the tank.”
“Okay, dear.” His answer came from further within the Police house. “There are some gingersnaps in the pantry if your friends want any.”
“Thank you, Inspector Cherry Top,” the two fillies sang as they replied to Pipsqueak’s other mom, a small, slim, blue-grey Unicorn mare.
“So where is Noi?” The colt then asked, referring to a pale olive Earth Pony, the absent member of their small group of friends.
“Oh, she’s waiting at her house.” Dinky Hooves, answered. “She’s helping her big sister, Carrot Top, bake carrot muffins. Noi’s trying to earn a baking cutie mark.” Dinky rolled her eyes at this.
“Another cutie mark?” Pipsqueak asked while he fished about in a drawer, looking for the cell keys.
“Didn’t we ask her to wait?” Berry Pinch cut in. The young filly wasn’t pleased.
“How many cutie marks does she have already?” Pipsqueak wondered as he led the way into the Police House. He knew that Noi having a cutie mark was remarkable in itself. Ponies their age wouldn’t reasonably expect a cutie mark for another two or three more years
“Three!” Dinky Hooves exclaimed as she followed behind Pipsqueak. “She’s a polymath. She has a pillow cutie mark from when Mr Davenport allowed us to try our hooves at building beds in his furniture shop.
“Dinky,” Berry Pinch joined the conversation. “I don’t think he allowed us in, so much as threw up his hooves while we walked in and started crying on a sofa with his wife, Mrs Button Stitch.”
“Well Scootaloo, Apple Bloom, and Sweetie Belle did make a mess before leaving.” Pipsqueak added a muffled reply, the key ring in his mouth dampening his voice.
“It wasn’t that bad once we put out the fire. We fixed Mr Davenport’s workshop real quick, didn’t we. I don’t think I’ve seen Mr Davenport happier than when he saw all the beds and pillows that Noi made.” Dinky said as she followed behind her other two friends. “Noi also has that magnifying glass cutie mark — ”
“I remember that one!” Pipsqueak yelled abruptly, dropping the key ring to the ground. “She helped both my moms solve the mystery of the Blue Carbuncle. Who would have thought that a goose would have swallowed Miss Rarity’s missing gemstone.”
“That’s two,” Dinky counted as she watched Pipsqueak pick up the fallen key ring. “And there is her chocolate ice cream cutie mark from when we were helping Twist’s mom at her ice cream parlour.”
“Three,” Berry Pinch shook her head. “She’s the only pony in our class to have a cutie mark, and she’s got three of them! Hard to imagine that she’s Apple Bloom’s cousin. That pony and her two other blank flank friends don’t have their cutie marks yet, and they’re three years ahead of us.”
“You, don’t like them much?”
Berry Pinch huffed in Dinky Hooves’ direction. “Not after what they wrote in their Gabby Gums column about my mom. They called her the town drunk!”
Dinky Hooves didn’t know what to say. She hated ponies calling her mom stupid just as much as her friend Berry Pinch disliked ponies talking about her mom’s drinking. “They did apologise.”
“She’s Apple Bloom’s cousin?” Pipsqueak managed to mumble his question.
“Second cousins,” Dinky Hooves replied. “Carrot Noi is a part of the Carrot clan. The Carrots, Apples, and Lemons are related. Carrot Noi’s grandfather and Apple bloom’s grandfather are brothers.” As she spoke, the Unicorn filly passed an opened door.
“Oh, hi Miss Applejack.” As Dinky Hooves waved, the orange Earth Pony seemed to drain of all her colour. “What are you doing in here?” The filly asked.
“My mom and I caught her and Miss Rarity,” Pipsqueak whispered as he continued walking past the observation room.
“Why?” Berry Punch’s voice drifted along.
“Where?” Dinky Hooves’ voice added.
“The library!” Pipsqueak’s voice drifted down the corridor.
“Why would anypony want to break into a library?”
“Maybe Miss Twilight Sparkle has the new Daring Do book? And they were super desperate to read it” Pipsqueak’s voice drifted through the open door.
“Don’t be silly, silly. It’s too early!” An indistinct voice exclaimed.
** *** **
Applejack had never felt so humiliated in her life, and pulled her Stetson hat to cover her snout and face. Her life was ruined. She was going to become like her uncle Calva, the black sheep in the family, a hoof for hire that would do just about anything for a hoof full of bits. ’Ya start small and before ya know it, ya have wanted posters from Appleloosa to Canterlot.’ She thought to her self.
After several minutes of self-loathing, Inspector Cherry Top walked through the door with a tea set floating with her. The inspector sat down on a cushion opposite Applejack and pushed a cup of tea towards her. Applejack personally didn’t like drinking tea much, but it was impolite to refuse a cup. Tea drinking was a national pastime. The sun princess was never seen without her cup of Earl Grey.
“Are ya going to question me?” She took a slip. The tea was pleasant enough for boiled leaves.
“Do I need to?” Inspector Cherry Top asked as she took a slip of warm tea with a gentle smile on her snout.
Applejack didn’t say a word. She didn’t trust herself to not get Rarity and herself into more trouble with the law.
Inspector Cherry Top lowered her tea cup, then, with a small absent gesture, tugged a stray bit of brown mane behind her ear. “I wish to apologise on behalf of Blue Copper. She hasn’t quite settled into life in Ponyville yet. She still sees crime in every corner, evil in every action. I hope you can forgive her for her transgression. She has been a little excessive.”
Applejack found that she could breathe again. She hadn’t realised that she’d been holding her breath. “Ah guess, ah can understand that. Lived in a big city mahself once with mah uncle and aunt Orange in Manehattan. It’s a bit more dangerous compared to country living.”
“Would you care for some crumpets? We don’t get many visitors at the police house. I have some of that lovely apple marmalade that Sugarcube Corner makes. It is simply delightful.”
“It sure is ‘cause it uses apples from Sweet Apple Acres.”
** *** **
“Now let’s go over this again.” Blue Copper glared as she tapped her snow white hoof on the table.
“I don’t think there is anything more for me to add.” Rarity answered.
“I know you burgled the Book and Branches library.”
“Really now? Breaking and entering with the intent to commit a felony therein. Might you have any evidence to support such a fallacious and fictitious claim? Have you searched my saddle bag and found proof of my dastardly crime?”
“Your friend has already confessed to being inside the library. Confess now and I can be lenient with the charges.”
“Well officer,” Rarity held up her fore hooves. “If you have all the proof you need, go ahead, throw on the iron bracelets and put me in the big house.”
The door knocked. Blue Copper turned at the sound. “This isn’t over, Rarity.”
“Oh, I believe it is, Copper.” Rarity smirked.
** *** **
“I’m not a smart pony, but I know she’s hiding something. My mane is itchy. I can just feel it.” Blue Copper glanced at her spouse.
“Dear, this is Ponyville. We aren’t in Trottingham anymore.”
“She’s too collected, Cherry Top.” The white mare insisted. “It’s as if I’m interrogating a professional. What’s more, I know she’s mocking me with her fake Canterlot accent. I think she actually speaks with a Neigh Jersey accent.”
“Blue Copper, Rarity isn’t some hardened criminal, even if she is putting on airs. She is the village seamstress, and might I add, the only seamstress in Ponyville. So unless you want to learn to do your own stitching, I think it would be best to be polite and courteous to Rarity.”
“Why would I ever need to learn to sew? You know I don’t like wearing dresses.”
Cherry Top winked coquettishly at her spouse. “You seemed to like wearing that Flash Filly dress for Baton and I the other night.” The smaller Unicorn kissed the larger mare on the lips. “Remember why we moved to Ponyville.”
“We wanted a safer place to raise Pipsqueak.” Blue Copper answered. “Less work, more time with the family. Maybe give our son a new sibling or two.”
“Or three, and that is exactly what we got with this transfer, all three of us. Nothing happens in Ponyville. The most is me levitating your drinking buddy Berry Punch to the tank so she can sleep off the alcohol, and Baton making sure the village stallions aren’t making too much noise on Weekend Cards Night.”
“I’m just trying to keep our home safe.”
“I know. Both you and our husband, Baton are doing your best. However I’m asking you to put aside the bad cop routine and let Rarity and Applejack go.”
“It’s not right. I know they were in the library.”
“Unless you have evidence to hold two prominent members of the community, we are going to have to let them go.”
“Just like that?”
** *** **
“Well that was bracing,” Rarity commented as she stepped out of the Police House.
“We were arrested!” Applejack was nearly beside herself from the dismissive remark. “We could have had a criminal record. Ah could have had a criminal record.”
“Pish posh! Nothing of the sorts, darling. We weren’t arrested, just invited for a cup of tea by Ponyville’s finest. Blue Copper was just fishing for information she didn’t have. Grandmother taught me a how to properly handle these kind of situations.”
“Um… Rarity, did you grandmother have many run-ins with the law?”
“Why would you ever say that? My grandmother is lovely mare. She has a heart of gold. Even when she was busy, she always made time to baby-sit me. Why, when I was a young foal we used to play a game called Tealeaf and Pigs. I really did love that game, although it really was just a game of catch. Grandmother had the wildest imagination. She even had me believing that we were running across the rooftops of Maretropolis, taunting angry pigs that tried to catch us.” Rarity smiled fondly.
Applejack could only stare with her mouth agape.
“One can only hope to age as gracefully as she has. I believe she continues playing our games with Sweetie Belle. She was ever so disappointed that I wouldn’t go into the family business. You see, father didn’t have the talent. So she placed all her hope on me, even calling me her little apprentice and sidekick. But alas for Grandmother, I was steadfast in my decision to become a fashion designer, even though I did get the right kind of cutie mark. One simply cannot allow one’s cutie mark to dictate one’s future.”
“Rarity, do you know the meaning of ‘tealeaf and pig’?” The apple farmer referred to the slang for thieves and police.
“Darling, I do know what pigs are, filthy animals that wallow around all day, doing nothing useful.”
Words failed her, simply failed her. Applejack was quite shocked to hear Rarity taunting the police after just leaving the Police House. On top of that, there was whole eye opener of her picking open Twilight’s window. Applejack didn’t want to think it, but the Mare-Do-Well costume did come together almost too quickly. Could Rarity…could she have a secret double life?
“You mean in the animal sense of the word?” Applejack asked slowly.
Rarity gave her friend a scrutinizing sidelong look. “You do have eight pigs on your farm. As for tea leaves, you put them in your teapot.” The Unicorn paused. “Are you alright, Applejack?”
The Earth Pony let out a small laugh. She was just glad that it was only her overactive imagination getting the better of her. This entire morning was a strange one. She was about to speak when Rainbow Dash appeared from out of nowhere, or so it seemed to her.
“Good gracious!” Rarity exclaimed, articulating surprise for both mares. “You shouldn’t fall out of the sky like that.”
“Yeah, yeah.” Rainbow Dash waved a dismissive hoof at the alabaster Unicorn, then turned her attention towards Applejack. “Well?” Ponyville’s Weather Manager asked rather pointedly as she excitedly snapped shut her wings
“Well, what?” Applejack replied.
“Did you get it?” Rainbow Dash whispered conspiringly. A wide grin was plastered on her bright blue snout as she came close.
“Come again, Dash?” Applejack was puzzled.
“Your trip to the library,” She began to wonder if Applejack was purposefully being thick today. She wasn’t a patient pony. “I heard you might have tried to sneak into the library without telling Twilight, and Blue Copper caught you.”
“Where did ya hear that?” Applejack was horrified. How did the news get around so quickly?
“I overheard some foals talking while I was working over Main Street. There was mention about you being caught breaking into Twilight’s library and something about the latest Daring Doo book, Daring Doo and the Goblet of Fire?”
“You mean, while you were napping on a cloud over Main Street.”
Rainbow Dash ignored Rarity’s comment. “So do you have it?” Her violet eyes sparkled with wild energy. “I heard rumours that Daring Doo’s author gave a special pre-release copy to Princess Celestia. Since the Princess is obviously a super busy pony, I’m guessing, hoping, that she gave the book to Twilight. Twilight’s a big fan. So did you get it? You can tell me.”
“No,” Applejack said.
“No?” Rainbow Dash paused. “No in that you didn’t get it. Or...” She leaned close into Applejack’s orange ear. “No, you can't tell me.”
“No, ah didn’t take it, and why in the hay are you only asking me? Rarity was there too. Ah’ve never stolen anything in mah life.” Applejack retorted defensively.
Rainbow Dash paused as she scrutinized the Earth Pony’s confession. If Applejack were any other pony, the Weather Manager would have treated such an admission with suspicion, more so when dealing with the latest Daring Doo novel. However, she knew Applejack, and that orange Earth Pony mare wasn’t called Honest Applejack without reason. That meant no new pre-release Daring Doo novel. It was disappointing, a bitter rain. Buck. “Then what did you go to the library for.” She cried out in frustration.
“Erm…” The Earth Pony trailed off, her eyes flicked to the side, looking anywhere except straight ahead. “We were returning a book?”
Rainbow Dash reaction was instantaneous and she began rubbing the bridge of her snout with the frog of her hoof “Seriously? AJ, I hope you didn’t tell Blue Copper that.” The pitiful performance was embarrassing to watch. “Even I can tell you aren’t telling the truth. So really, why did you break into Twilight’s library?” She pressed.
Applejack opened her mouth to answer. To be honest, she wasn’t quite sure what she hoped to say. She respected her friend’s privacy, and if Twilight Sparkle chose not to tell everypony in Ponyville that she had a foal, it was her right. Yet, having now been forced to think, Applejack had to admit, it did hurt just a little that Twilight didn’t trust her, and by extension the rest of girls, with the news of the new foal. Hay, she hadn’t even seen the foal yet. Weren’t they BPFF, Best Pony Friends Forever?
However if she were in Twilight’s horseshoes, she couldn’t be sure if she would have done any different. Marry your cousin, sure. Applejack didn’t like the stereotype that city folks cooked up, but it did happen on occasion. It couldn’t be helped really, as every pony was bound to be related to every pony else in a small village. With your own brother on the other hoof... your own ‘married’ brother, her thoughts stressed. Applejack wanted to rub the back of her head. How the hay did these things happen?
As a friend, she should keep the matter under her hat until Twilight was ready. However, anything other than the honest truth often led to more problems in the long run. Thankfully, Rarity chose that moment to speak
“Not here.” Rarity primly cut into Applejack’s long pause. “Somewhere more private.”
That got Dash’s attention, and Applejack got the feeling that she shouldn’t have been so thankful after all.
** *** **
Rainbow Dash eyed Rarity wearily as the Unicorn mare closed the door of Carousel Boutique behind them.
“So what is the big secret?” She asked. From the way Applejack was acting, she suspected it might be something more serious than Pinkie Pie’s confession about her reoccurring Cupcake Nightmare. That one still gave her the willies, better not think about that. “Never going to eat a cupcake again,” the rainbow-maned mare shivered
Rarity cleared her throat, signalling she was ready to begin. “Before I continue, I must extract a solemn oath that you will not repeat what you are about to hear. It is of the utmost importance to our friend, Twilight Sparkle’s reputation, and the future of more than one life.”
Rainbow Dash rolled her eyes. Rarity was such a drama queen.
“What you will hear will shake the very foundation of morality and,” Rarity stressed, “I will not tolerate any judgemental behaviour or attempt to reprimand our friend. Twilight has already gone though the most stressful experience in anymare’s life, alone, without the comfort of family or friend.”
Applejack glanced at Rarity. “Wait a second there. Are you sure we should be telling Dash this? Didn’t ya promise Spike not to tell anypony?”
“Applejack dear, she already suspects something is amiss. Keeping her in the dark would merely escalate this incident out of our control.”
“Ah don’t know…” She trailed off uncertainly.
Rainbow Dash didn’t like being ignored. “’She’s’ standing right here you know.”
“How about this? Rainbow Dash darling, what if we decided to not tell you anything?” Rarity asked.
“I’d pester you a bit” Rainbow Dash answered.
“Should our lips remain immovably silent?”
The Pegasus mare paused. “Aw… I’d fly over to Twilight’s and maybe bring along Pinkie Pie. It is her lunch break, and she has a way of getting stuff out of Twilight.”
Rarity turned to the orange Earth Pony with Rainbow Dash’s statement as her final deposition. “And thus you see why we must share this secret with her.”
Silently, Applejack nodded her head in acceptance.
“Do you promise not to repeat what you are about to hear?”
“I swear. Cross my heart and hope to fly, stick a –”
“Don’t finish that!” Rarity yelled.
“Pinkie Swear?” Rainbow Dash questioned.
“Yes, I don’t know how she does it, but whenever a pony even considers reneging such a promise, Pinkie Pie simply pops out of nowhere. How she does that I do not know, but she is absolutely one of the ponies we must not tell.”
“I don’t know.” Rainbow Dash replied. “The last time we kept something from Pinkie, she kind of took a trip to Crazyville. It’s like we aren’t trusting her and breaking a friend's trust is the fastest way to lose a friend –”
** *** **
Elsewhere, in the kitchen of the Sugarcube Corner bakery, Pinkie Pie had the sudden, almost irresistible urge to run to Carousel Boutique and shout ‘FOREVER’.
“Pinkie dear,” Mrs Cake paused midway between frosting a cake. Pinkie Pie was still, a far off stare in her eye while her tail cotton candy pink tail twitched. “We have to finish cakes for the afternoon lunch crowd.” That was enough to snap Pinkie Pie from what she saw.
** *** **
“Be that as it may be,” Rarity replied. “What Twilight cannot afford right now is an unplanned Pinkie Pie welcoming party.”
“Okay. Okay. I got it.” Rainbow Dash replied. “So what do you want to tell me?”
Rarity took a breath and steadied herself. “Twilight Sparkle has recently given birth to a filly.”
“Twilight’s a dam? No way. You’ve got to be joking.” Rainbow Dash expression was one of disbelief. Canterlot mares were always thought to be so proper. “And if you are joking, I’ll have to tell you the joke is lame. Like super lame, broke my leg lame. That isn’t funny.”
“I’m only speaking the truth.” Rarity replied. “Barely a week ago, Twilight secretly gave birth to her daughter.”
Rainbow Dash turned to Applejack. She was the only pony that would tell her straight. “AJ?” Rainbow Dash asked.
Reluctantly, the Element of Honesty told the honest truth, as she saw it. “It’s true. Twi has a foal.”
“So who’s the father?” Rainbow Dash asked wide eyed. “Is it Caramel?”
“No!” Applejack interjected, a bit shocked that her cousin was being mentioned. “Why in tarnation did you think it’s mah cousin?”
“Well,” Rainbow Dash began. “He kind of attracts eggheads. I mean Wind Whistler is dating him. So if she is seeing Caramel, I thought Twilight might be as well. Birds of a feather flock together. Egghead mares, forming an egghead herd, having egghead foals. Although, I don’t know what a smart mare from Maresachusetts Institute sees in him.”
“What’s wrong with a smart mare seeing something in mah cousin.” Applejack demanded. Family pride was at stake. “Sure, he ain’t as Earth Pony strong as Big Macintosh, but ah'm sure he has his charms when he isn’t behind the apple stand.”
“Have you heard Wind Whistler speak? She is way more brainy than him. Her words are so big, that I need a dictionary whenever she speaks to me about getting permission to do her research on wild weather over the Everfree Forest. She is like a Pegasus version of Twilight. I just give the approval stamp on all her stuff so I can get away from her long presentations.”
“There nothing wrong with mah cousin.”
“So, if it isn’t Caramel, who is it? Big Macintosh?”
Applejack was about to speak her mind, when Rarity waved her off. “I did say it would shake the vary foundations of morality. If our Twilight Sparkle had a relationship with either Caramel or Macintosh, there would merely be some head shaking. But no, the sire of Twilight’s foal,” Rarity paused for the dramatic effect, “is Shining Armour.
Rainbow Dash dropped onto her haunches, shocked. “No bucking way.”
Rarity slowly nodded. “Our Twilight Sparkle has entangled herself in a forbidden, incestuous love triangle.”
Rainbow Dash glanced at Applejack again, who hesitantly nodded her head. “Ooo…Eew. Eew.” The Pegasus mare squeaked and her body gave an involuntary shiver.
“That’d explain why Twilight was so upset after finding out about her brother’s marriage. She was jealous!” Rainbow Dash paused. “Wait, it has been only like a year since Shining Armour and Princess Cadance’s wedding! They must have done it just before the wedding.”
Applejack was silent as she listened to Dash. Fancy mathematics was never her strong point, but she could count. Dash was right. The timing fit. One year, an eleven month pregnancy. She always assumed that Twi was naïve, with foal like innocence, when it came to the opposite sex. She never showed interest in dating or the few single stallions in Ponyville. But now…Did Twi give her brother one last farewell the night before the wedding?”
“Oh, Twilight, it’s not like you didn’t have options.” Rainbow Dash cried. “You have a sweet flank. If only you had put out some, worn a bit of clothes or a saddle, instead of spending all your time in the library naked…” Rainbow Dash paused when she found Applejack giving her an odd look.
“What? There’s nothing wrong with one mare complimenting another.”
“Ah didn’t say nothing,” Applejack looked away.
“It’s the mane, isn’t it?” Rainbow Dash replied defensively. “I was born with it, okay. It’s naturally coloured rainbow. You can look at the roots. I’m not dying my mane just because.”
“Is there a colour called rainbow?” The blond, country Earth Pony mare had to ask.
Rarity cleared her throat, catching everypony’s attention. “From my sources, Twilight’s daughter is named Wisp and she is, as of today, one week old. Twilight has been so dreadfully ashamed that she hasn’t been seen in public since her daughter’s clandestine birth.”
“Well, it is time for action.” Rainbow Dash jump back onto her four hooves, seemingly recovered. “I’m going to buck her behind out of the library.”
“You can’t do that.” Rarity threw her body across the front door, all but barricading it.
“Rarity, she can’t raise a foal isolated in the library.” Rainbow Dash reasoned. ”That’s just a bad fairy tale. The mare in the tower... well ivory tower. Wisp has to come out sometime and ponies do go to the library on occasion.”
“Rainbow Dash, I don’t think you quite realise the gravity of the situation.”
“Twilight did the nasty with Shining Armour -there is the ick factor- and had a foal. But seriously I’m cool.” She leaned over and whispered into Rarity’s ear. “Ponies out here do it with their cousins all the time,” Rainbow Dash said quickly as she glanced over to Applejack. “Twilight just did it with one less degree of descent.”
“Might I add that her brother is married to an Alicorn princess,” Rarity continued dryly. “We have on our hooves not only a forbidden, incestuous love triangle, but also a royal scandal. As of this moment, our Twilight Sparkle is the Other Mare in her brother and sister in-law’s marriage. A mare he cannot possibly add to Princess Cadance’s matrimonial herd without triggering an uproar amongst the Canterlot nobility and pony society in general. Furthermore I am told Princess Cadance is unaware of this affair.”
“Okay,” Rainbow Dash admitted. “More complicated than I've expected. But I am so going to see Twilight’s little tyke.” Rainbow Dash answered back excitedly. “Just to make sure she’s healthy. It can’t be good to have spent your entire life in a library, even if it’s all of one week’s worth.”
Rarity was suddenly hesitant. “Rainbow Dash, dear, I must caution you. When you do have a chance to look at Wisp, please…” The alabaster Unicorn paused trying to find the right words. “Please, be kind.”
“Eh?” The cerulean Pegasus had puzzled look on her face. “So she got hit by the ugly stick or something?”
This was news to Applejack, “Something the matter?”
Rarity sighed, thinking back to what she heard from Spike. “I fear that Wisp has a congenital birth defect. There was mention of Wonderglue and a prosthetic to make Wisp look more presentable.”
“Ya mean Twilight’s girl is- ,”
“The same as Noteworthy?” Dash finished for Applejack. Everypony in Ponyville who used prescription glasses knew of Dr Noteworthy. He was Ponyville’s sole optician. Both mares stared at Rarity with varying degrees of horror.
Rarity bowed her head in reply.
Dr Noteworthy was a charming stallion with a cultured taste for operatic music, as his cutie mark of two pairs of backwards-facing quavers suggested. The slate blue Earth Pony stallion wore a fanciful blue mask that hid half his face and snout. It lent quite an air of mystery around him whenever he attended the monthly meetings of Ponyville’s chamber of commerce. So lifelike was his mask, that a pony at times could imagine the mask followed the contours of his face precisely
Rarity had seen behind his mask once by accident and knew that was not true. On the eve of that dreadful Grand Galloping Gala two years ago, she had been looking for a pair of stallions to pull the carriage Twilight had conjured from an apple. Her cat, Opalescence, in her excitement had mistakenly dispersed the mice turned horse, which Twilight Sparkle had meant to pull their magic apple carriage.
She was at his practice, using her feminine wiles to charm him into the task. It was then, by fate or misfortune, that the strap of his mask snapped off. There was no handsome noble behind the mask, or as the florist trio, Lilly, Rose, and Daisy constantly speculated, the handsome visage of Prince Blueblood’s twin. That poor stallion had the most grievous disfiguring injury she had ever seen. She had screamed and fainted in dead fright upon his polished floor. Where half a pony face should have been, there was a hole, a wide gaping hole. Dr Noteworthy had only one eye!
“Take my camera.” Rarity said to Rainbow Dash. She had apologised profusely to Noteworthy, but it was weeks before she could speak to him again without staring.
“I would like a photo of Wisp.” She levitated the expensive device from its place on a high shelf, out of Sweetie Belle’s magical reach. “Maybe… maybe I can make her a hat or give her a mane style that’ll highlight her better side.”
** *** **
Comments ( 116 )
Post Comment
Refresh
Oh shit.
Oh buck me.
This is going to end really badly. There really is no good way for this to end for anyone involved.
That said, you really are doing a mare-vellous job of winding us up.
Keep going, good sir! We demand more of this confusion and mistaken incest!
I did laugh when I read about Twilight giving Shining a farewell present.
And he gave her one back! *Cackles
Mistake on the last paragraph. Devise should be device.
Cheers
GM
Hey, this is featured. Cool.
Current 'Forbidden, Incestuous Love Triangle' Count: 4 total, 2 this chapter
Finally, there are 5 references that I am aware of in this chapter. Whoever finds them all first wins a prize. I'm still working on what the prize will be, but I swear on my nonexistent authority as this story's editor that there will be something.
I'm following this out of morbid curiosity as to how much of a train wreck this turns into.
Taking bets now! Anyone for believing that all three Princesses will be involved by the end of the fic? Any takers for at least one of them going off the deep end? How about theories for how long it'll take for Rarity, Rainbow Dash, and Applejack to learn the truth? To say nothing of Pinkie Pie and Fluttershy?
>>771402 Well in this case (as opposed to say, Lesson Zero) her fears may be justified. Wisp (assuming that she is Chrysalis and Shining Armour's) is a national security threat, being a changeling, AND her brother's illegitimate child. While Cadance very well may be an incredibly understanding pony, this is a topic that just doesn't go over well, ever.
Well, at the very least we're looking at emotional abuse, possibly physical abuse, the near-annihilation of the monarchy and the whole rape issue resurfacing.
If, IF Cadence does accept Wisp as an illegitimate child ( And didn't that work out for Jon Snow ) then there is a new Princess in the circle. Assuming she maintains her shape-shifting power then you essentially have the entire monarchy called into question. Especially with the invasion debacle.
And let's not forget others wanting to get their claws into Wisp. Being able to command the entire Changeling hoard by proxy? Very tempting.
Sounds mare-vellous. :D
When's the next chapter?!
>>771541 *Applies censor-filtering glasses* Whoa, are you serious? Geez...that's going to end up badly for everyone.
*Ponders* Actually, it'd be hilarious for Twilight to try and explain to them that not only is she a virgin, but she didn't play Sunshine Sunshine Ladybugs Awake with her brother.
http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3h8zgs7KL1r3xauuo1_r1_1280.png
Oh yeah, and that's she's raising the rapebaby of the Queen who basically roofied her brother.
...Honeydew "Rapebaby" Wisp.
*Is shot*
Hehehehe.
Ok, so this is a pretty intriguing read. I love all the confusion and drama floating around this tale so far. Also, Wisp seems to be quite an interesting OC, the first one I have ever read or seen about, and I've read a lot of fanfics over the months. Of course, once people read this, there will undoubtedly be Alicorn/Earth/Pegasus/Changling crossbreeds all over the place.
Heck, I'm thinking about creating me a Changling crossed with somepony now 
Anyaway, can't wait till there is more. You've earned a thumbs up, favorite, and a watch from me.
That's why humans manufacture multiple varieties of bovine milk. Whole, 2%, 1%, and Skim all refer to the fat content of the milk.
Also, don't forget: Ponies are sapient; thus, they'd have speed...and also smarts. Human milk probably has some endurance bonuses as well as the brain boosts.
We now present, in a brief snippet of text and emotes, The Reaction of Princess Columbia:
Princess Columbia: *sees the title and description snippet in the Feature Box* Oh, that could be interesting! 
(Reading begins)
Princess Columbia: Oh, wow! Instant sympathy for the foal, author obviously done research...I'm liking this! 
(Yet more reading)
Princess Columbia: This is a freakin' page turner! 
(Less than two hours of frantic reading later)
Princess Columbia: *reaches the end of the most recently published chapter* 
...FUCK!!! Now I have to wait for more!!! 
Seriously, though, this is fantastic!
My only objection was the seriously strange detour with the fillies talking about one with a triple cutiemark that didn't really fit with the rest of the story. You could replace the entire conversation with one about the merits and economy of kumquats (which, btw, was indeed a word I knew before a certain party pony used it on the air, and in fact I have tried one. They're a wonderful citrus treat and I'm seriously derailing myself here) and the rest of the story wouldn't have been impacted in the slightest. Again, that's my ONLY complaint!
Keep up the excellent work...and do it quickly, please? Between Mendacity, Composure, Falling Stars, Sharing the Night, and this, I'm on a serious "WHAT HAPPENS NEXT?" freakout! The last time I was this on edge waiting for the next chapter was for The Moonstone Cup, and before that Past Sins. (NYX LIVES! Long live the Nyxian Alliance!) 
FOUND A REFERENCE.
How did no one see this?
I deserve a prrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrooooooooomotion.
Okay, you've got me hooked. I am genuinely, emotionally invested with this story. Everything about this story so far has been great.
Rarity completely misunderstanding the situation is just awsome to me for some reason. If only she'd just simply confronted Twilight directly, this never would've happened. The scenes with Twilight, Wisp and Nurse Redheart add some great drama. The fact that Wisp herself is the princess of an enemy species is pretty dramatic all by itself.
I'm not to good with long reviews, so I'll just say this. The story is funny, dramatic and plays out like a My Little Pony episode with just a few themes the show would never do added in. Overall, it's a great story and I hope you continue to deliver out some good writing. 
Image: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/31471793/FiMFiction/emoticons/lolface_Queen_Chrysalis.png
Image: http://dl.dropbox.com/u/31471793/FiMFiction/emoticons/misc_Redheart_gasp.png
Image: http://i299.photobucket.com/albums/mm282/SasukeRox_TentenToo/Smiley.pngError: “What you will hear will shake the very foundation of morality and,” Rarity stressed, “I will not tolerate any judgemental behaviour or attempt to reprimand our friend. - If the speech is continuous, it needs to be a comma.
Suggestion: “Why would any pony want to break into a library?” -> “Why would anypony want to break into a library?” (anybody - not 'any body').
Suggestion: “Don’t be silly, silly. It’s too early!” An indistinct voice exclaimed.
There are a couple more errors...
Oh boy now if they tell Pinkie Pie the jig is pretty much up and we've got a scandal like no other, and if they don't Pinkie Pie might suspect something and if that happens bam it's 'Party of One' all over again. 
As for Fluttershy she'll likely be scared for life if she finds out. 
Such sweet chaos, Discord would love it, if he weren't sealed back in stone. 
This fic is fantastic. When I read the premise I figured it'd be yet another Secret-Changeling-in-Ponyville story, albeit with a bit of a twist. But Wisp herself has only been directly involved in a handful of lines, the whole rest of it is about Twilight awkwardly trying to handle the ramifications of the situation and her friends running wonderfully wild with half-true speculation and the best of intentions. And the characterization has been superb.
I particularly liked the references to background fanon. Ruby Pinch bailing out her mom from the drunk tank, Noteworthy's cyclopean moment, and the hints of since-erased-from-history adventures with Doctor Whooves.
Religion aint got nuthin' to do with it.
This is basic horse mating behavior anthropomorphized a bit for human readership consumption. It just happens to look like the human concept of polygamy. Rarity's and Nurse Redheart's blase treatment of the issue shows that the one-stallion-multiple-mares relationships are not only accepted but so common place as to be equal to monogamous relationships in Western culture.
Main plot is super interesting. Will follow this!
But the conversation of the three foals in this chapter felt pretty odd. With them talking about ponies they knew and both describing and naming them in the same sentence. Not to mention Noi with her three cutie marks.
And little Pip seems to have quite the interesting family. Then again with the Mare/Stallion ratio that I remember from the show, it might be perfectly ordinary. 
The Noi thing is a reference to the fact that the animated character shows up with different marks in different places.
Has anyone mentioned The-Turning-of-the-Screwball---The-Strange-Case-of-Button-Stitch yet? Another reference, and well worth a read.
“Afternoon Dinky Hoovefs, Berry Pinch,” Pipsqueak greeted as he came around the Police House front desk. “The usual?” He turned to the greyish-rose filly.
Got an extra 'f' in Dinky's name.
And somepony has got to set those three straight before they blurt out their erroneous conclusion to the wrong individual.
>>774681 Depends on how many plot arcs get written. Current vague skeleton looks something like:
Arc 1 (where we are now): Slice of Life
Arc 2: Slice of Life, possibly Sad
Arc 3: Adventure-ish, possibly dark/sad
Arc 4: Dark-ish, possibly tragedy/sad
*Please note, all of this is subject to change, and all of these may or may not happen (each very well could be a standalone story, or not happen)*
Just read through the whole thing and I have a style note: It is usually considered bad form to use numerical symbols is this sort of writing. Instead, you should spell the numbers out. For example, use 'three' instead of '3', and 'seven' instead of '7'. As a stylistic error, its on about the same level as not capitalizing names, IIRC.
Also, I'm not really a fan of the whole 'polymath with multiple cutie marks' thing. It flatly contradicts known canon, as we had a whole episode showing that it is all but completely unknown in the modern day for a pony to have multiple cutie marks, and then that possessing multiple cutie marks is actually a symptom of a nasty, ancient disease. Every departure from the established canon should have a reason related to advancing the plot, to avoid distracting or confusing the readers. For example, Noteworthy's animation glitch presumably isn't part of the in-world canon, but it was used to provide an example of a disfigured pony that Rarity (and the readers) would be familiar with, helping advance the reasoning for why she decides to take the actions she does. The multi-cutie mark pony, on the other hand, does not appear to serve any such purpose, and just violates canon for no reason.
Other than that though, I am enjoying this story. Thanks for writing.
I've made the corrections. I didn't realize that I used single digit numbers in numeric from within the text.
On multiple cutie marks.
Multiple cutie marks is rare in G4 but not entirely unknown despite what Diamond Tiara and Cheeriee said in the Cutie Pox episode. Aside from animation errors such as 'Noi', there are ponies walking around with two cutie marks.
Examples are Trixie, which is a crescent moon and a magic wand. (Strangely enough) Berry Punch which a bunch of grapes and a strawberry. Davenport which is a feather and sofa. The vet, Mane Goodall who has a cutie mark composed of a dog, cat and a duck. There is Screw Ball but I am not sure if she is really a pony or some strange agent of chaos.
And there are ponies like Rainbow Dash and Shining Armour. Their cutie marks are composed of two different elements that are touching one another. So it may just be one cutie mark representing a complicated concept... or could it be two cutie marks, two talents that are very closely linked to each other. So RD may have a talent for weather control(cloud) and speed(lightning bolt), or it could be a talent for awesome speed; A bolt of lightning of out the blue (lightning out of a white cloud). Shining Armour, power(stars) and defense(shield) or protector of the Princess (royal shield bearer)
With these examples, I thus hope that I can persuade you that the idea of multiple cutie marks is not that contrary to canon as it first appears.
I admit it was clunky to throw in Pip and his friends, but it was to introduce two Chekhov’s Guns for future story arcs (that may or may not get written).
1) multiple cutie marks, that ponies can more than one special talents. This relates to Wisp and her own cutie marks. What does a pony do if your special talents are near opposites of each other?
2) Carrot Noi, the most talented pony in a 1000 years
Both are to force Wisp's story to end on a happy note. Because as it currently stands, the logical conclusion of Honeydew Wisp's life is tragedy and ruin. And that is not how FiM:MLP stories are suppose to end. Friendship always wins, even in the face of in-story biological realities and Chrysalis playing a Batman gambit.
Princess Celestia has good reason to banish Wisp's entire breed to a fate of slow starvation and eventually extinction. "The good of the many outweigh the good of the few." I imagine this is a phrase that guides Princess Celestia's actions by day and hunts her every night.
The story plan is epic. I actually have a story outline that follows Wisp through her entire life but I am not sure I can actually write it all. Four major arcs are planned, but I would be happy to finish this one arc.
Thanks for the reply. On the subject of the cutie marks, I have to disagree on the multiple cutie marks thing. It isn't just Cheerilee, Twilight also says she's never seen anything like it when she sees Applebloom. Plus, cutie marks are always referred to as singular, even when they have multiple parts. The talents might be broad or narrow, and open to interpretation, but they all make sense as singular cutie marks. Davenport works at a shop that sells nothing but quills and sofas, which is reflected in his cutie mark (and raises something of a chicken and egg question). The vet's cutie mark is a number of different animals, signifying her connection to all the different types of animals she treats.
The large, six pointed star that is on both Twilight's and Shining Armor's cutie marks is a preexisting symbol, which presumably symbolizes magic. It is also on the Element of Magic in the storybook opening of the pilot, the breastplate that Shining Armor wanted to wear, which he mentioned belonged to is favorite uncle, and several of the decorations in his house. Twilight's cutie mark's central star is overlayed on another, which likely represents herself, and is surrounded by five other stars, which probably represent the friends she has been connected to ever since the first rainboom. Shining Armor has a shield and three stars, in addition to the double overlayed central stars, which likely means that there are three ponies that he is connected to, who he will protect with his magic.
Also, Trixie doesn't have a crescent moon as part of her cutie mark. You can get a good look at it at about 17:30 in Boast Busters, when the Ursa Minor almost falls on her. The 'crescent moon' is actually a trail of sparkles coming out of the magic wand. Think of how, in the Harry Potter books, Harry's wand reacted when he picked it up for the first time in the wand shop.
Screw Ball, as you mentioned, can't be taken as representative, thanks to Discord. Also, Screw Ball is likely a reference to the old Warner Brothers short Duck Amok, which is probably one of Discord's favorite shorts.
Also, make sure to keep in mind that any pony in ponyville with more than one cutie mark is going to be rather isolated, thanks to their run in with a single case of the Cutie Pox. Towards the end, quite a few ponies were wearing hazmat suits, and everyone in town knows that multiple cutie marks is a symptom of a disease. Even if you decide to alter canon for this story to make multiple cutie marks a thing, you'll need to keep in mind how everypony in Ponyville will react to seeing a young pony with multiple cutie marks again, and explain why Twilight didn't recognize it as anything but an illness. If, as you are suggesting, multiple cutie marks is a sign of being a polymath, then Twilight (who considers a unicorn who lived prior to the founding of Equestria basic history that everypony would know) should have been able to recognize it, so it doesn't make sense that she did not.
On another subject, this story is actually somewhat close to my personal headcanon for how Changelings raise their young. My take on it is that they steal away a pony's foal, and replace it with a Changeling foal, who takes the shape of the real child. The Changeling foal then grows up with the ponies, loved in place of their true child. Meanwhile, pony child is raised amongst the Changelings, and is spoiled rotten so it will love them, until the age when he or she starts to question certain things, like why he or she is different, at which point the Changelings abandon the pony, who has been spoiled his entire life, and has no idea how to survive on his own. At around this point, the Changelings would come for their child, and take him back, as the cuckoo'd parents are probably drained dry by this point. Basically, a slight adaptation of the changeling myths from European folklore.
I ask because the current ark is 7 chapters long. And looks to only be about 3/4 of the way done.
Then I hear there are supposed to be four arks.
I don't know about you, but that sounds like epic length to me.
however, I understand your desire to see this ark finished.
-Delta-
>>780312 Regardless of if she had seen Appleboom's condition before, Twilight found the Cutie Pox information after a short amount of time reading through books, indicating that there is a large amount of things that she has never seen before, but that she is a skilled researcher.
On the subject of cutie marks, and whether or not a pony can have more than one, let's take a closer look at Davenport. He has a quill and a sofa, but what does this mean? If it's a single mark, that would imply that his talent revolves around quills AND sofas combined, such as selling the two items together. But if this is the case, that would also imply that he would be incapable of selling one or the other well. To me, this seems absurd. It would be illogical for him to be incapable of simply doing one without the other, it's much more likely that he has talents for both, but that they are independent of each other (two unique talents, two unique cutie marks). It could be argued that it's a single cutie mark, and that it signifies that he is a talented merchant, but seeing that he literally ONLY sells quills and sofas, this is unlikely.
Or it could mean that he is excellent at writing about sofas, and is able to create excellent ads for his shop. With this interpretation, the shop might originally only have sold sofas (and likely other furniture), and Davenport added quills to the merchandise (and the name) as a reference to his cutie mark.
Also, If I may point out, the first book that Twilight went looking through after seeing Applebloom's condition was a book of diseases. Not a book on cutie marks, of which I am sure some exist, but a book describing diseases.
I totally suspected that one of the fillies would have two moms... it's just so obvious, but Pipsqueak? IMPOSSIBRU! With one mom looking kinda the same as Pip... I think?
"Tea, Earl Grey, Hot!" Princess Celestia ordered her servant.
The two moms have a husband too? Baton must be a player, fo sho!
They are taking a while to actually talk to Twilight about this shizzle... but I suppose that holding the truth for a later chapter increases the suspense, and makes me like this story more.
Yes, it was. Previous chapters were also heavily referenced, although to events that occurred within the series. To give make my own story world more tangible, I use other fics. Often I imagine some version of events that happen in other fics, happened in my world. It give the characters history and thus direction.
For instance, in my world, there is a pony named Button Stitch. She is married Davenport. She does run the shop, Curious Notions. And went wound too tightly, she does turn into Screw Ball. However the reason she does so is different.
The economical relationship between Zabrica and Equestria is similar to that hinted in FoE. POD (Point of Divergence) between the two worlds is the birth of Honeydew Wisp.
I don't know what I can't believe more. The fact how breeding is portrayed here, that you plan on it being sad, Noi seeming to be overpowered, the discussion between editor and fans or the fact that I agree with fans on this one.
Considering most ponies we have seen have only one cutie mark, I don't think having Ponies with more is a good idea. A pOny can be good at something other than their cutie mark, considering Celestia is powerful, leads a nation and raises the sun while she has only one Cutie Mark. Trixie's cutie mark was exactly one amd the Quills and Sofa pony... Seriously? So you think that because a pony has two things as their cutie mark they can only sell it combined and not separately? Remember the Flim Flam brothers. They had their Super Speedy Cider Squeezy 6000 and they clearly were inventors but one had Cutie Mark reflecting 3/4 of an apple and the other one had the rest of it, yet they build machines and sell cider, not parts of apple. Go back to The Call of Cutie episode where Cheerilee explained her seemingly odd Cutie Mark. While I like to read about heroes getting stronger as they work on somethIng, Noi gave off the feeling of unneeded Mary Sue. There are many ways to let the story end happily and Mary Sue is the worst
>>867572 The fact how breeding is portrayed here - Family structure in this story is based on actual equine herding structure, and (at least in my opinion) it makes sense given the gender ratio that is always displayed in the canon show. Having said that, it's certainly unusual compared to how most everyone writes it.
That you plan on it being sad - The circumstances surrounding Wisp's birth certainly have lots of potential for sad, and if the story went on long enough, would become practically inevitable.
Noi seeming to be overpowered - This seems to be the general consensus. I'll keep this in mind while editing later chapters, but I'm not going to try and tear into her yet.
Discussion about multiple cutie marks - Yeah, I'm not going into that again; I've given my opinion, others have given theirs, but until canon comes out and says how exactly cutie marks work, that is neither here nor there. Again, will keep in mind during further editing. Honestly, I'm still surprised how much discussion this generated.
I disagree about the Mary Sue as is, simply because she just isn't established enough. All that's known about her at this moment is that she has the rare condition of multiple cutie marks.
Thanks for the feedback. Aside from a couple aspects of the world, what do you think of the narrative itself (pacing, dialogue, stuff like that)?
Let's see. Dialogue is nice and done correctly. The pacing of the story is not too fast but perhaps on the slow side. I was suprised by Rarity being so oblivious to what her grandma really did. I however have this odd condition where when the stuff is drawn out too long I skim over the text fast focusing fhe most on what I find most interesting and then come back to it. I was kinda hoping for some cute scenes of Twilight taking care of Wisp in library but I'm afraid it did not happen. You see, these scenes of Daaaaaw moments can draw in people easier than the talk of unrelated to story(yet) ponies. But The story is written correctly and I approve.
And I am writing this on Iphone so it took some time to write this review because every time I try to press space I press N
>>868709 Who's to say there won't be D'awwwww moments later (Please note, this is not a statement for or against the potential, I'm just the editor, not the author. Although I certainly hope there will be) after the awkward misunderstanding is dealt with. It's only been a week so far. Hmm... I liked the talk between Pipsqueak and friends (there's just something about the mental image of the CMC setting a furniture store on fire 
), but then again, if the comments are anything to go by, I obviously have a very different thought process than most people.
This story had so much promise despite problems with grammar and style. But then you had stuff about "herds" which I notice some other stories have too.In the show, it is clear that ponies are monogamous, as we are. And then you really jumped the shark with meta references "Daring Do and the Goblet of fire" Really? I will continue reading to see how this turns out. But don't give up, I'm sure you'll do better as you get practice. When I tried my first fanfic (age14 war of the worlds sequel) it was terrible. Now I'm a bit better but still improving.
P.S how do you add emoticons? I've seen lol Luna and some others but I don't have.
Umm question why is it they don't think it's a good idea to tell Pinkie Pie? If I had a secret I just had to tell somepony and only had the choice of the mane six Pinkie would be the first one I'd tell. She DID INVENT the Pinkie Promise after all. Rarity and Applejack would be the last two I'd tell to too, along with Rainbow and Fluttershy since I wouldn't want to burden her with something like that. So confused and a little pissed at Rarity. Still liking the story though but if it was me I would have just approached her by now, not letting on I know anything but saying I'm worried about her and she could trust me with anything. Why don't they just DO THAT? They don't have to even let on they know anything at all. Just a friend worrying about another friend.
OK heres another stupid thing these damn mares can't put together. One they were with her a LOT of the time during the Royal Wedding. Two Twilight only interacted with Shining three times it seems during the course of it all, two in public with WITNESSES and the third at his house while Chrysalis was there. Three the time for her to have had intercourse and then had the baby just seems we'll either too long or too short. Can't decide which but how are they SO sure! I'm sorry but can't ANYPONY ASK FOLLOW UP QUESTIONS! Everypony in this universe has a case of don't-ask-follow-up-questions syndrome.
EDIT: Still cannot decide if it was too long or too short but here's why. A mares pregnancy can vary a LOT. Take this line quoted from wiki-answers; ' A mare can carry her baby for 11 months or more as some mares carry it for 11 days short of a year and some a year.' So when AJ said the timing was right, it implied that ALL mares (well at least to me) carried their foals for exactly 11 months when that is not true. I'm sorry if it sounds like I'm bitching at nothing and I REALLY do love this story but the characters just piss me the buck off!! I mean they just assume that Pinkie will immediately throw a welcome party when they could just have her Pinkie Promise NOT to tell anypony. This is why if I was ever in the same situation as Twilight I'd tell Twilight first then Pinkie Pie. Then tell the rest of the Main six together. So no one gets really bitchy or things like that. But by that point if I stay locked up in my house like Twilight they would probably come over and see if everything's ok. Cause that's what friends do. 
EDIT 2: OK so another thing that I forgot to mention above. The night before the wedding SHE GOT TRAPPED UNDER GROUND! Now AJs just being stupid cause she had to tell them she got trapped. So the conclusion of her giving her brother a farewell the night before the wedding can be ruled out completely since she was TRAPPED UNDER THE BUCKING GROUND! I'm sorry I just----...
'She had screamed and fainted in dead fright upon his polished floor. Where half a pony face should have been, there was a hole, a wide gaping hole. Dr Noteworthy had only one eye!' I'd like to hear that story. You should do a phantom of the opera style story or something like that cause I'm interested in this one eye thing. Very cool 
I can accept a compound Cutie Mark, wherein different parts of said mark represents a different aspect of their talent. Take Apple Bloom. Please! *Da bum bum CHING!* Ahem. So far in the show, she has been shown as having a knack for fixing up old club houses, and helping Zecora with her potions. These two appear to be seemingly unrelated skills, until one realizes that they both call under the broader scope of "Making and Repairing Stuff". As such, my current head cannon Cutie Mark for her would be a hammer and some other tool (hoofsaw?) crossed under a shaman's mask. A compound Cutie Mark. Each piece representing different things. All of which are different aspects of her special talent.
Additionally, I'd accept a compound Cutie Mark, wherein each separate piece represents a different talent. A singer who is also a wonderful cook may have something like this. Going for years as a Blank Flank, until BOTH of his talents were realized, and only THEN getting his/her Mark.
As such, I hope to Faust that Noi gets reworked before she becomes plot relevant. Three separate and unrelated Marks are a sign that something has gone completely and abhorrently wrong.
Cancel
Send
