• Member Since 2nd Jul, 2013
  • offline last seen Sunday

River Road


Writing Comedy, Adventure and Slice Of Life. Desperately trying to keep up with all the crazy stories my brain comes up with.

E

My name is Octavia Philharmonica and I am in Ponyville to play classical music with two of my bandmates.

...Right?


Cover image put together just for this story by the ever awesome Nightmare Nyx

Chapters (2)
Comments ( 46 )

“My name is Dr. Timothy Hooves, and I am Time Turners grandson.”

DO I SMELL A SEQUEL TO THIS AWESOME STORY ALREADY?! :pinkiegasp:

4306058

*quickly adds Author's Note*

4306136

*Squeeeeeeeee*
The 500-Follower-Girl is reading my story~! :pinkiehappy:

“Well, what is it then? Is she your clone? A changeling? A shapeshifting alien? Your time-travelling granddaughter who came from the future to save Equestria?”

“The last one,” both mares interrupted. Octavia stepped up to Vinyl, keeping a neutral expression. “My name is Melodia Philharmonica, nice to meet you.”

Vinyl, you mean our time-traveling granddaughter. :rainbowlaugh:

Dammit, now I almost feel compelled to make a sequel. :rainbowderp:

4306163 :twilightblush: I'm nothin' special~

4306175

To ship or not to ship. Well, it's not actively implied in the story, at least. I wonder if I should consider this a sequel to the other one I wrote.

4306223 It's strange, though -- my twin daughters for OctaScratch are named Harmonia and Melodie... :rainbowderp: Great minds think alike, I suppose!

4306211

Nothing special, she says.
You're right, though. If you make a sequel of this, you won't be special, you would be super-ultra-extreme-awesomazing! :heart:

4306233

Or maybe I know that because I'm somepony's time-travelling grandson?
Dr. Timothy Hooves, pleased to make your acquaintance. *bows* :moustache:

4306252 Ok, it's official, I'm making that sequel. :rainbowlaugh:

4306256

Success! The time-space continuum has been saved from paradoxes once more. :trollestia:

4306278

What! Impossible! Lies and slander, I say!
...
*goes to change tag*

Comment posted by WublessFeat deleted Apr 28th, 2014

Coherent enough not to be random... :pinkiecrazy:
Has at least one line of backstory... :trixieshiftleft:
A 'heartwarming' ending... :trixieshiftright:
A sequel that plugged in two time travelers... :rainbowderp:

Yup, mustache. :moustache:

Applaud, Good Sir.

Interesting that it was the one who turned into Octavia who developed an independent identity opposed to the other two.

All in all, this is a story after my own heart.

And I thought I was the only one who wrote fanfics based on the question of self and identity of artificial ponies.

And Rarity has no idea she brought this Octavia into the world out of another pony.

And there's the idea black magic has to be inherently evil rather than just "handle with care." But the created Octavia isn't evil.

http://alexwarlorn.deviantart.com/art/Inspiration-Manifestation-Family-At-Nowhere-450622349 My own inspiration written after I saw the episode. Though I'll admit about a million times weirder than yours and set with a lot of my own fanon, so not as accessible.

Poor Magic-Tavi, alive just long enough to regret losing her existence. This is a very well-done story.

And here I thought that Octavia and her band were just teleported from Canterlot.

4307077

Why, thank you, thank you very much. I'll have you know that all my stories are quite coherent. :raritywink:

4309046

Ahahahahaha :rainbowlaugh:
Don't be silly. Now where would be the fun in that? :derpytongue2:

4307694 4307712 4307779

Glad to hear that. Keep in mind, though, that while the new Octavia isn't evil, she is still occupying the life and place of an innocent mariachi pony.
As for the "the question of self and identity of artificial ponies", I think neither of us can compete with Merlos and his Thunder Struck story for that. :twilightsheepish:


4307883

Thank you. Would you believe that at first I thought I would have to tag this story as Sad? :rainbowderp:
Sure glad it didn't have to come to that.

4309068

Really? How does his story relate to 'artifiacal ponies' tell me more.

I WAS WONDERING why this story was missing a 'sad' mark.

And what you're saying Ironically I once wrote as part of an original group story, where a woman was remade into a replica of a child who had been friends with a trio of witches when they themselves were children but had died. Years later after the witches were defeated, the heroes decided NOT to change her back, because they decided they'd be committing one murder to undo another murder.

Rather like the conflict in the Voyager episode Tuvix, were an transporter accident fused two men together into one person. By the time a solution has been found, Tuvix has developed his own ego and identity, but the crew decide to split him anyway, much to his own dismay. His last words being more or less, "You're all good people, and you're all going to have to live with this."

Yes, the innocent pony who was used as raw material is an innocent victim, but so is Created-Octavia. And this makes me wonder if Rarity's other 'revisions' developed individuality in that time.

4309291

Well, it's not easy to summarize, but let me assure you that it is An undoubtedly amazing Sweetie Bot story.

As for Octy, she still considered herself as Octavia, which means that in her interpretation of things there would still be one of herself living on. I... might have subconsciously given her some character traits of Quizzical Greystone. :twilightsheepish:

As for tags, I didn't use the Sad tag because the story turned out mainly comedic and taking both of them makes no sense. I don't even think it is possible on this site.

4309879

Now I'm left how things went with her two 'siblings' and if they developed any individual will before they were erased.

4311173

Harpo probably got too wasted to notice or care and the other one is just a nameless background pony. :trollestia:

4311251

Ironically, 'nameless background ponies' are my specialty.

First chapter ended kinda darkly but the epilogue lightened it :pinkiehappy:
4306256 I anxiously await this.

4315308

I couldn't just let a story end on a sad note, now could I? :pinkiehappy:
Anyway, thank you very much for the comment, it means a lot to me. (And I hope The Queen Princess wasn't just joking about that. :twilightsheepish:)

Okay, so Rarity's dark magic turned the mariachi pony into perfect copies of Octavia and her friends?

Does that mean that when Twilight fixed everything, the Octavia copy turned back into a mariachi pony?

4647165

That is indeed what it means.
But that doesn't mean that Octy is just gone. :raritywink:

4647714

Do the mariachi ponies have any memory whatsoever of what happened?

4655756

Maybe, maybe not. But I doubt it.
Not that Twilight wouldn't give them a short rundown of what happened.

Very cute, the ending is especially a nice touch.

This story inspired a twist on my own Pinkie Pie Variety Show.

5375333

Oooh? Well, doesn't that sound interesting. :raritystarry:

Okay I was not expecting that at all so apparently Rarity's Magic or at least the dark magic that Spike gave her really took a toll on the ponies who got teleported or transform into Octavia and the others but she felt like she was her own but not really it's kind of confusing at first but Vinyl and Octavia the real one actually try to help her but that's when Twilight came around how to fix the dark magic that Rarity made and Vinyl Scratch wanting to stop her from making her disappeared because she's actually a dark magic but artavia at least the one who got transformed wanted to do this because since this is not really her so she let her do the magic spell and I think she disappeared that turned really sad very quickly

Whoa once again I did not see that coming and you know it kind of explained about the other one who looks like Octavia during the apples reunions but because there are two Octavias she needs to disguise herself and apparently there's another one who kind of looks like Doctor Whooves but that turns out to be his great-great-grandson wow that was a turn of events and also pretty sweet that Pinkie Pie helping Octavia and vinyl bringing back the other Octavia back this was a pretty good story keep up the good work

Login or register to comment