• Member Since 11th Aug, 2013
  • offline last seen Feb 10th, 2023

AmethystFire


"We must let go of the life we have planned, so as to accept the one that is waiting for us." Joseph Campbell

E

After being held captive in a dark, damp and cold cell room. The only comfort she has, is voices of ponies screaming... But after she is rescued, she can't do the most important thing to life... Her destiny and the elements.

*Thanks to firebirdabirdoffire for editing my story*

Chapters (3)
Comments ( 15 )

I like where this is going! I really, really like where this is going!

...I like this, great concept and idea...but still, all the grammar mistakes are disturbing the atmosphere, and it feels too rushed. What you need is an editor to fix these problems. Don't worry, there are a lot of groups with people that can help you with this, all you need to do is ask, and they will be willing to help:twilightsmile:

Imma have to agree with 3346410 here they is some grammar mistakes and the chapters are a tad too short.

The plot is great and there's feeling so yea.....

Ill like and fav it.

It's pretty good so far. But this story is missing some tags.

They all looked at me and Pinkie answered, " Jewel Charmer, has lost her voice and is in her own room, she is dying..."

It think there's a word missing between "Jewel Charmer," and "Has"

3347490 I don't think so... There's a comma but that's all that is there.

The story has been fixed thanks to firebirdabirdoffire for editing it for me. I'll do better in the future. Thx for the faves, comments, and likes on this fanfic.

Top notch job, Mate. One of the best examples of short/sweet I've ever seen. It says what it needs to say with no filler, and says it well.
Mechanically, excellent, with no discernable flaws. Five Shattered Skulls out of five.
Plot: It's extremely gripping. The first chapter left the reader wanting to read on and see what happens, and the second chapter does that tenfold. Five Shattered Skulls out of Five.
It flows well, with no unnecessary pauses or delays. Five Shattered Skulls.
Overall, a very rare rating from me, but Five Shattered Skulls out of Five. Good show, RainbowShy. Excellent show.

Hi, your neighborhood firebird here. I overlooked a typo on the first chapter.

No more words that I can say. My heart sank. What will happen to me? The rest of my life... Will I loose my friends?

The word I underlined needs to lose an "O"

3453791
Okay I'll fix it for you!:raritywink:

Like other said I like the idea of the story and what you're going for.

But the story was too rush for me to really get in to it... so some feels.

I came across this more or less randomly and thought I'd give it a look. I guess I mostly agree with several of your other reviewers: there's a good idea here, and I can see what you're going for with the feel. The idea of a pony sacrificing (some of) her voice to help somepony else is an interesting one, to. But it all seems a bit rushed.

The main thing I think could do with some background/explanation is the line about "Discord followers". In the show, Discord has never had any followers, so unless this is meant as an AU fic, you really need to explain somehow to the readers why those followers exist. Also, how did they capture Fluttershy? She has high resistance even to Discord himself, so I doubt any lesser followers could capture her without a clever trick.

There's definite potential in this story, but I think it does suffer from the really short chapters. If you'd made each chapter the length the whole story is now (so the whole story about 5,000 words) you'd have had more space for it to breathe. Stories of under 2,000 words rarely work too well unless they're one-shots.

A FABULOUS STORY, BUT IT NEEDS TO BE FLESHED OUT. is something wrong with her eyes? she seems to see only blobs, and it didn't appear to be getting any better. I like the premise, but it seemed more like a sketch, instead of a complete picture. even, as is, I would like to see the story continued.

Login or register to comment