• Member Since 18th Jul, 2012
  • offline last seen Oct 25th, 2017

Horsegirl123


Brony

E

It never meant to happen; it never should have happened. It was obvious that no one knew, nor was ever supposed to know. But becoming a princess gives you some insight, and the reason for my transformation soon became very clear. Princess Luna was dead, and I was to going to give her life.

Chapters (10)
Comments ( 109 )

I like where this is going. Continue please :twilightsmile:

Pinkie and Surprise (me): CELESTIA!! WHAT DID YOU DO TO LUNA!? YOU KILLED HER DIDN'T YOU!! CONFESS AND FACE THE WRATH OF THE PARTY PONIES!! BRING DOWN THE TYRANT!!

Oh... Crap. :twilightoops:

Luna: That's what I'm supposed to wear ro Twilight's coronation? 'Tia, I wouldn't be caught dead in that dress!

Celestia: Funny you should put it that way...

I thought this was going to be a one-shot, but at the same time I'm glad it will get to develop a nd i can keep reading!

NO I FRIGGIN HATE CLIFFHOLDERS TO THE SHADOW REALM WITH YOU

So, is Twilight replacing Luna, or is Celestia going to kill her to bring Luna back? If the latter, I will look forward to this even more. How will Celestia handle being Twilight's killer? How will Luna handle the knowledge that her sister killed her first friend to revive her? Give me another chapter, and I will favorite this story.

interesting X3

Oh? I'm intrigued.

Hmmm... What is up with Luna?

SHE'S CHOKING TO DEATH! :pinkiegasp:

2703834

Wait, its legal to use not-pony emoticons? :pinkiegasp:

Alright you've got my f8ve. ;;;)

Uh oh.... Sh:twilightoops:t's going to hit the fan soon, i'm sure of it. I think that that is not actually Luna though, maybe an imposter that Celestia hired to fool Twilight.

OH MY GOD!! SO DESCRIPTIVE I SWEAR MY EYES ARE GONNA EXPLODE! I LOVE THIS FIC! THE SUSPENSE, THE CONSPIRACY, THE EVERYTHING!! I HAVE TO TELL PINKIE!!

More to this story than meets the eye. I like how you wrote the events after. Very different than how others do it, and in character you could say. Namely some of Twilights internal dialogue and interaction with Celestia. Everyone goes through how she addresses the Princess, but you did it differently, if not more believably. Then follow up the characterization with the table scene. Gets the same message across by showing. Speaking of her standing upon the Royal Sisters entrance and following their table manners.

There were a few mistakes, or rather clunky phases I remember reading, but as long as the story isn't something I've seen time and time again, and everything else stays, any mistakes are forgivable. Looking forward to further chapters.

Ohhhh.... I am starting to get it...

I think...

You have piqued my interest, please, do continue this.

CELESTIA LIED ABOUT NIGHTMARE MOON AND SHES PLOTTING TO KILL LUNA! :pinkiegasp:

Interesting, I hope this doesn't end with a alicorn murder-fest. Because I think it is.

Hm. So, the real Luna is trapped inside her own head, and can only talk to Twilight when her body is asleep. But why is Celestia keeping her sister's mind locked inside, and who is the personality masquerading in Luna's body when she is awake?

Okay, confuzzled now. Can't wait to see where this is going!

Comment posted by Princess Celestia deleted Jun 17th, 2013

It's obviously Bob the flying Dutchman.

It seems like Celestia may have cast some sort of perception spell which forces Cadence -> Luna. Twilight has seem to have forgotten all about Cadence, though what that means is...

Very, very interesting...

Ohoho, I was right! Celestia is using another pony to pose as Luna, in this case it's probably cadence.

This chapter, 10 outta 10

2732887 i cannot divulge until later

Well, things are entering mind screw territory.

Well, then it makes sense that luna wouldn't have been in the wedding, but what about the scene where she is in the tower? Cadance was in the cave at that point... Hmmm... Or maybe, Chrysalis was Cadance since 1000's of years ago and had just made her appearance... I'm sooo over-thinking this

UMH what happened to twilight's mind its Cadence

"Princess Luna is dead?"

Gasp! :pinkiegasp:

2705426 DON'T FOR THE LOVE OF CELESTIA DON'T TELL PINKIE YOU WILL END US ALL!

OMYGOSH OMYGOSH OHMYGOSH!! This story gets more suspenseful every chapter!! I LOVE IT!!

Strange, I have this favorited, and I didn't get the update alert.

Ahh! She said it! She said the title! :pinkiegasp::pinkiehappy:

>Everybody's shocked

Really? I hope that everyone's being sarcastic.

I don't know why Twilight's freaking out. It did say it was a rumor, and she just saw Luna not three minutes previous.

Oh, Luna is dead, WHO COULD HAVE GUESSED?( pay no attention to the title of the story ), not saying it was boring, just saying that it wasn't unexpected.

Umm....
I've read all 5 chapters of the story so far, and primarily feel confused.

The summary says "Princess Luna was dead, and I [Twilight] was to going to give her life."
Princess Luna appears to be present (with waiters etc. interacting with her), and acts "normal" most of the time, excluding the times she is cryptically begging for help. Obvious hints that Celestia is hiding something (said something at least being that Princess Luna is dead),
Twilight for some reason not remembering an alicorn with "a candy swirled mane and bright magenta eyes" who appears to have been present at all of Twilight major life events. Cryptic statements and hints that "Nothing is real" and "Everything is wrong". :applejackconfused:

2767095 yup that was on purpose. Everything will tie together very soo, i promos

And now I must wait for the conclusion... which seems so close yet so far away...

Man Twilight... You unintentionally broke the fourth wall. I'm gonna have nightmares.

Login or register to comment