-=[The Equestrian Critics Society]=-

The best place on the site for quality reviews and critiques, guaranteed.

Story Requests

Looking to get your story in the review cycle? Here's the place to line-up!

[Currently Full and Locked]

Reviewer Applications

Want to have the cool status of being a TECS-class reviewer? Click here to find out how!


These are the rules for both requests and forum posts. Super important that you check them out!

-=[Current Events]=-

We've brought on another admin, who will be focused on organization and overall management. Please welcome Smiles!

In other news, I am looking at changing our rating system. Because our reviewers and members aren't always on skype, I feel that posting a forum post would get more input than direct messages or skype.

I am looking at making this a rating based group, out of necessity and in part due to the demand for guiding reviews that rarely seem to be received as detailed critiques but more as a general rating...

Click here to read more!

-=[Fic of the Month]=-

April 2014


Comments ( 170 )

#372465 · 4d, 2h ago · · ·

I know no one will see this but I have to try

"magic in the stars" by Australian chaos is a amazing story that will touch your heart. Please read it

#369572 · 4w, 8h ago · · ·

If you have the time can someone review this got a few likes making sure this was not a flukeyou can always trust me also my newest story if you want this won't be easy

#369485 · 4w, 18h ago · · ·

I have an incomplete comedy story that I'd like to be reviewed by someone. I have editors already that have also critiqued it, but i would also like at least one "proffesional" opinion, persay, before continuing as it is. Where can i submit the story for critiquing later on(I undertand the queue is full currently)?


#365276 · 9w, 2d ago · · ·

>>362083 When more people volunteer as reviewers and actually stick around to review.

#365107 · 9w, 3d ago · · 1 ·

Um I'm knew diet think this should be counted as story so here you go last line plagrized

Let me tell of my most loyal of friends

Who has stayed by me till the end

You who stalked when you were alwakys welcomed to walk

You who coldness brought comfort to my skin

You whoom known since my first day

You who cuddled with me during the day yet at night held me tight

You who I always will adore you my most loyal friend

So it is with these solem words I say

"Hello darkness my old friend I've come to talk with you again."

To Luna


#364399 · 10w, 3d ago · · ·

Permissions required for this action were not met (action: Adding story to group folder)

What does that mean?

#362083 · 13w, 4d ago · 2 · ·

When is the "Story Requests" folders not "Full and Locked"?

#361962 · 13w, 6d ago · · ·

Hello. I'm new to this website and currently working on my first story about Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo. I was wondering if you could look at the first chapter and let me know what you think. Thanks! ;)


#361262 · 14w, 5d ago · · ·

Hello! I am a new writer to Fimfiction and have a story that I'm currently working on, but since I was looking for more input than I've been recieving, I figured I could join groups of like-minded people and ask their opinion and critique of my story. Thus, I've joined this group, but I'm not sure what to do next.

To submit a story to a group for critiquing, do I simply post it as a comment on the front page like I've seen others doing, or is there another, more formal, way of adding a story to this groups' "que"?

Thank you for your time and I hope to find (and share) many stories via this site!

#357528 · 18w, 3d ago · · ·

Can I get some criticism on my story? It's my first story I plan on going through with, and I need criticism or motivation to keep going. http://www.fimfiction.net/story/177202/pipsqueak

#356922 · 19w, 1d ago · · ·

I'm sorry, but I'm a bit confused with what I'm supposed to do. I just really wanted to join cause I'm looking for a editor for my latest fic Equestrian's Crippled Daredevil since I can't edit for my life. (Getting a lot of misspelled comments or wrong words to use)

#355004 · 21w, 3d ago · · ·

Can somepony review this (p.s. not mine):

The Scratch

#354204 · 22w, 2d ago · · ·

Hello I was wondering if u guys can check my first chapter so far I just begun writing it?

#347465 · 29w, 3d ago · · ·

How do I get my story in this group for review?

#345167 · 31w, 5d ago · · ·

I can't add my story... :applecry:

#342797 · 34w, 4h ago · · ·

Ooooo, cool, looks like my story will be getting reviewed soon! :raritystarry:  Just a little heads up to whoever's reviewing "Batmare Begins"; two more chapters are incoming this Wednesday and Friday, respectively, both of which will be significant additions to the plot.  Just thought you'd like to know so that you don't get a review out before they're uploaded.  Hope whoever's reviewing likes my fic! :twilightsmile:

#341533 · 35w, 2d ago · 2 · ·

Uh, how long before the folder is 'unlocked' looks like its that way for quite a while. This group isn't dead is it?:ajsleepy:

#340680 · 36w, 1d ago · · ·

Goodbye everypony! I am leaving. Bye-bye!

#339625 · 37w, 2d ago · 1 · ·


Here is the problem with liking MLP but not the friendship bit. (in my eyes)

The sappy friendship and emotional bit is the reason for the rest of the show. Think of the show like a book, the characters and the scenery are all there to show the point or the conclusion. In the end the characters could be anypony as long as they are still engaging and likable, but the idea of it being okay to be kind to people, honest, loyal, generous, and happy, is an idea that is rare in popular culture these days.

So when you watch MLP, remember that the sappy bits are good, they are showing you how to be a good friend and a good person, whereas a lot of the other shows out there only want to show you what explosions look like.

#339299 · 37w, 5d ago · · ·

Heres something id like to ask all who have seen my little pony iv seen all episodes but i wanna to ask i like it its funny and the characters have potential, animation and acting are good but i Hate the sappy, friendship, harmony, together stuff if their are others like that id like to chat with ya

1 197544

Newest Members

1d, 9h ago
1d, 10h ago
1d, 16h ago
2d, 7h ago
Professor Tacitus
2d, 14h ago
Mile High
4d, 2h ago
4d, 21h ago
1w, 2d ago
1w, 2d ago
1w, 3d ago