Applejack was in Ponyville she looked up in the sky smiling for what she did it was morning she had time to ask a pony to come to her barn. She saw Fluttershy Applejack went infront of her “Oh uhm Fluttershy.. Where is Pinkie pie?” she asked Fluttershy gasped “Pinkie.. Uhm I don’t know.. she vanished” She said Applejack chuckled and smiled “Oh do you want to come over for somethin’ Fluttershy in the middle of the night?” she asked Fluttershy thought about it “Oh I don’t know Applejack.. Im busy taking care of animals but okay I will your my best friend” Fluttershy replied Applejack smiled and walked off Fluttershy went back to her cottage.
Mr.Cake went to Applejack “Excuse me Pinkie pie went missing and she said she was going to your barn in the middle of the night and she didn’t come back today” he said Applejack eyes widen “Oh Pinkie we had lots of fun she left but I think someone got her or she went somewhere else in Equestria!” Applejack smiled Mr.Cake left Applejack smiled and one of her ears flickered.
Applejack had to sing a little song but not in public it was about the thing she done she she went in the barn and pretend she was faking fixing up the barn and she sung “Oh, Poor little ponies out there who I choose to be victims my friend Pinkie noticed that oh yes she did! now somethin’ is goin’ on with me I just love to do this its my hobby I lie to get away with it or I am in big trouble by Celestia. One, two, three. Come on lets start this lets spray it I make stuffed ponies I eat there meat for dinner. My dinner is there meat and hay but when I eat by my family I have to cover the meat with a lot of hay. But it doesn’t stop me from hurting these poor ponies who I choose to attack. Next will be Futtershy that little brat who wont try to be brave but sometimes she does. She is such a brat! Now lets put her to the bravery test threw the things I did to Pinkie this time she would be made into a plushie a pony sized plushie who I can snuggle with at night here in this barn and do as I like to the Fluttershy plushie. I will keep hunting everypony until my family and the princesses are the last ones standing!” She stopped and chuckled she put her hoove on Pinkie pie’s head “Im sorry Pinkie but I was planning to get you next I already did the same to your pet GUMMY!” She laughed as she got gummy who was made into a plushie and put it on Pinkie pie’s head. She danced all around.
Applejack stopped she danced until it was the afternoon she went out of the barn and closed it “Still broken” she said outloud She went to do her chores she kept doing them until half of the trees where with no Apples it was almost night the others has gone to bed early while she stayed up.
Applejack did some Cider for Fluttershy. Fluttershy cane and took the Cider she took a sip and fell to the ground and fell asleep Applejack grabbed her and dragged her into the Barn she strapped her up and make sure it was Secure and she giggled while she was in the dark Fluttershy woke up she was scared she wanted to go home “Whats happening Applejack? Where are you!?” she screamed “Oh Fluttershy whats wrong scared” Applejack replied Fluttershy’s eyes widen Seeing somthing in the Darkness “I have a song for you.. Now.. let me start. Fluttershy I think your a brat when it comes to your kindness I choose you to be my next victim. You are so shy and wont be brave for once so this is your test on being brave I will let you go if you pass if you shed one tear you fail and go threw the horrible things I will do to you.. I am going to make you into a plushie!” Applejack sung to her she went into the Light Flutterhsy tried to be brave but she shed a tear Applejack stabbed a knife into her stomach “I said to be BRAVE you BRAT you have FAILED now you are going to be made into a Plushie my friend” she said Fluttershy’s eyes where very blurry she could hardly see a thing... Applejack cut her open but then stitched in back together she made a cut in Fluttershys neck she tried to breath but instead she closed her eyes and stopped breathing. Applejack licked her neck alot and unstrapped her and put her on the matchine and turned it on she was split inhalf Applejack took all the meat out of fluttershy and ate some of it she licked inside to taking everything out. She waited for the blood to dry when she did she stitched her up and snuggled with her “Fluttershy my dear, your job is done for taking care of your animals now your mine to snuggle with forever until you rot “ Applejack whisped and she did a smirk.
Applejack got up and went out of the barn daylight came and everyone thought she was still burnt Applejack looked around “Its alright everypony im fine. No attetion needed I was fixing up my barn and got red paint all over me that wont wash away” She said She went back into the barn after thinking about her next victim she Snuggled with the Fluttershy plushie and did a angry like grin.
Applejack walked around she was worried that someone was watching her for what she did to Rainbow dash Applejack had to take a bath she was dirty she went inside Sugar cube corner and went into the bathroom with the tub. She turned the water on and jumped in she washed her self really really hard. She finished up and the bath water was red she gasped and drained the tub she jumped out and dried herself off she walked out of the bathroom and saw Mr.cake glaring at her with a face that made him seem like he knew her secret.
Mr. cake grinned "We finally heard what happened to Pinkie pie Big Macintosh told us, she was at your barn you where the one who killed her" he says Applejack pinned him down "Do not tell anyone if you do I will go for you next" she threatened him Mr.cake nodded in agreement. Applejack got off of him and went out of Sugar cube corner. Applejack walked in the streets of ponyville going home she got mad at her brother quick. She went next to Big Macintosh "Big Mac you told Mr.cake about my secret. So to keep your mouth shut about it I will do one of your chores everyday only one" She says Big Macintosh smiled Applejack went back into ponyville and went to Rarity "Oh Rarity would you like to come over in the middle of the night" she asked Rarity smiled "Well of course my dear"Rarity said Applejack went outside of her house and trotted back to the barn once she got there she got everything ready. Rarity giggled "Maybe not"she added she turned around and Applejack was already gone Rarity rolled her eyes. Applejack got everything set up she did one of Big Macintosh's chores and went back to what she was doing she grabbed gummy and tossed it around waiting for Night to fall.
She kept playing with the Gummy plushie but it landed right into Fluttershy and Rainbow Dash she smiled it was becoming night she grinned waiting in the darkness for Rarity to walk in. She waited but no one came she got mad she waited for another hour and still Rarity didn't come. Applejack kicked her Barn doors open and galloped to Rarity's she jumped into the window breaking the glass and went into Rarity's room she took a needle and stabbed her. Sweetie belle saw it "Applejack! I trusted you!!!" she cried Applejack looked at Sweetie belle as she grabbed Rarity's body and put it in a bag "You tell no one about this!!!" she yelled Applejack dragged the bag and threw it out the window she jumped out of the window and grabbed the bag and put it on her back she went to her barn and closed the door dropping the bag and opening it up she took Rarity and put her on the machine and poked her with the shot she gave Rainbow dash before. "Huh? Applejack? Where am I?" She says hearing the machine she gasped Applejack made it go faster and it was she took everything out of Rarity and stitched her back up "No one doesn't says yes and doesn't come over!" she yelled and threw her to the wall.
She walked out of the barn she sighed she looked around making sure Mr.Cake didn't tell anyone if he did she will have to go after him. No one looked at her she walked around ponyville looking for someone to attack next.