//------------------------------// // The More, The Creepier // Story: Ticci Toby in Equestria // by IntentWings31 //------------------------------// Toby was furious. He adjusted his crooked bandanna and started charging towards Dash at full speed. She tried to dodge But was grabbed by the tail and slammed against the crystal floor back first. She could hear her friends call out her name. As she laid there groaning with her eyes closed and teeth clenched. She felt pressure on her chest. She opened her eyes and saw Toby standing over her with his foot pressed against her chest, holding her down. He looked down, but instead of Dash, he saw a very familiar man's corpse covered in blood and stab wounds. He looked up to see he was not in the crystal room anymore, but in his old dining room. He heard a scream from behind him and turned around to see his a woman. Why did this all seem so familiar to him. Then all at once he remembered. This was the day he killed his father. He grabbed his head to try and get rid of the memory of his past. He began to feel dizzy and the room began to spin around him as he stumbled back and fell to his knees. He closed his eyes and when he opened them again he was back in the crystal room. Everyone watched as Toby was acting like he was seeing something that they couldn't. Almost as if he was somewhere else entirely. Masky and Hoodie ran to Toby, who was starting to sweat and breath heavily. Masky knelt down and put a hand on Toby's shoulder. "Toby. What happen?" He asked to try and calm him down. "S-S-S-She s-saw me k-kill him. T-The way she l-l-looked at m-me. W-W-Why d-did she h-have to see." Toby said. Back On Earth, Slender's Forest Slendeman was teleporting all throughout the forest trying to find where his proxies disappeared to. He made sure to have a telepathic connection to them so he will know where they are at all times. They were in one of Hoodie and Masky's clearings in the forest and then one by one they just disappeared. He has already searched the entire forest and couldn't find a single trace of them. He went to the clearing where they last were to see if he had missed anything. When he got there he saw someone standing at the opposite edge of the clearing looking around. He had a bloody white hoodie with black pants and long messy black hair and carrying a whisky bottle. Slenderman knew this person very well. It was Jeff the Killer. Slender felt pure rage at the thought of Jeff doing something to his proxies. He teleported in front of Jeff and rapped a tendril around him before he had time to react. 'JEFF!'He screamed in Jeff's head. Jeff looked up at Slender with surprise. "Huh, so it finally talks." Jeff Sneered and looked at Slenders right arm. "I see your arm grew back nicely, such a shame. I was hoping it wouldn't grow back. So, do you mind putting me the fuck down, or will I have to burn down another forest." He said in an irritated tone. Slender slammed Jeff against a tree, leaving a huge dent in it and almost knocking it over. 'WHAT HAVE YOU DONE WITH MY PROXIES!' Jeff recovered from the pain quickly and replied. "What the fuck are you talking about!" 'Jeff, I can make your life an unimaginable hell. NOW TELL ME WHERE THEY ARE!' Slender said in a dark tone then went back to screaming. "I DON'T KNOW WHAT THE HELL YOUR-" Jeff cut himself off as he suddenly realized something. "OH yeah, I heard about these three weirdos that always hang out in this forest. They're yours?" He asked. 'Yes, and the last place they were was right here and then they just vanish! I come here and find YOU here! That gives me reason to beleive that YOU did something!' Slender said "Listen Slendy, I wasn't even here at the same time they were. I was to busy running from-" Jeff tried to explain but was cut off. "JEFF!" A female voice yelled. They both look to were Jeff entered to see a girl with paper white skin with black hair, eyes, lips, and clothing holding two extra large kitchen knives. "...Jane." Jeff finished. Jane turned towards Jeff and walked up to him, completely ignoring Slender. "There you are. Now listen up. Just because I get to your next victims house first and are about to kill them DOESN'T MEAN YOU CAN JUMP THREW THE FUCKING WINDOW AND TACKLE ME LIKE THAT! SERIOUSLY! WHAT THE FUCK!" "I'm tired of you always stealing my kills!" Jeff responded. "And you think that-" Jane was cut off as the group heard someone clear there throat from behind them they looked to see who it was. Slender recognized her immediately. It was a girl about Toby's age with a pale skin tone, long messy brown hair. She wore a white tank top under an unzipped blue jacket with gray jeans and black fingerless gloves. Her most notable feature was her face. She had a cut in smile like Jeff, but it had stitches running along the cuts. Her left eye was replaced with what looked like the clock of a small pocket watch. Jeff chuckled as he looked at the girl. "I like the face. Might want to lose the stitches though." Jeff said. He looked at Slenderman. "Hey stretch, mind putting me the fuck down now?" Slenderman looked at Jeff and promptly slammed him to the ground hard, still holding on to him. 'There I let you down.' he said. Jeff glared up at Slenderman. "So the over grown twig has jokes now. You knew what I meant fucker!" "Oh shut it Jeffery." Jane said. "You deserve it after the things you've done." Jane then turned her attention back to the girl. "Who are you?" She asked. "Just call me Clockwork." Clockwork replied. She turned to Slenderman. "Um, Slenderman, have you seen Toby anywhere? I can't find him. The only thing I found is this creepy dog that keeps following me around." She stepped to the side to reveal a husky sitting down with a giant, almost human smile. "Smile?!" Jeff exclaimed in surprise. "I told you to stay at the house!" Jeff yelled. Smile Dog's ears flattened against his head as he looked down and wined. Jane raised an eye brow at Jeff and asked. "Where in the hell did you get a dog like that." "Well" Jeff began. "I found a picture of him, then a couple days later he just showed up and started following me. I liked how he looked so I kept him. OH! And watch this. Smile!" Smile's ears perked back up and he looked at Jeff. "Spread the word." Jeff told Smile. Everyone watched as Smile Dog's fur turned red as his eyes began to glow and the black fur on his head and back grew into long black hair. It almost looked like someone ripped his skin off leaving only muscle and hair. Jeff began to laugh. "HAHAHA! Good boy. Now back to normal." Jeff told Smile. Just as Jeff commanded Smile changed back. "Anyway." Clockwork said looking back to Slender. "So, have you seen him." Slender looked at her. 'Clockwork, do not panic, but Toby, Hoodie, and Masky are missing' Clockworks eyes widened. "W-Wha- Missing!? They couldn't have just disappeared!" She exclaimed. 'Sadly they did. I have been trying to-' Slender was cut off as he started to hear a voice. S-S-S-She s-saw me k-kill him. T-The way she l-l-looked at m-me. W-W-Why d-did she h-have to see. It was Toby's voice. Toby was remembering. Slender let go of Jeff and started to follow the voice. He walked to the middle of the clearing and stopped. He stood there for a minute. He felt a strange energy. Slender knew this kind of energy. It was the energy left behind from a portal. He consumed the energy to try and use it to create another portal. He concentrated on forming the portal. As he did this the portal slowly started to fade into existence. Once he was finished he turned around to the group of Killers. 'I think I might have found where my Proxies have gone. Stay here.' And with that said he turned and walked into the portal. "Hang on! I'm coming too!" Clockwork yelled as she ran through the portal after Slender. Smile Dog barked and ran after Clockwork. "Hey! No Smile! Bad dog!" Jeff yelled as he chased after Smile. "I'm not letting you get away that easily Jeffery." Jane mumbled before running through the portal after Jeff. The portal was not able to keep stable after five entities have entered and collapsed in on itself.