Just Five Nights · 5:33pm Nov 4th, 2014
All right, I do believe I promised everypony a scary story, and unfortunately, the mods here didn't accept it. Apparently, they think it has basically nothing to do with MLP, so they're not accepting it.
Doesn't mean I can't post it on other sites.
Which I did.
Finally using my fanfic.net account for something, please enjoy Just Five Nights. If it does relatively well, maybe I'll follow up with more chapters.
As long as pony characters are in in and it isn't breaking any rules, they should accept it. Did you try messaging them back explaining the mix up? I remember them originally rejecting the first chapter of This Can't Be Happening but they admitted their mistake and put it up when I pointed out that it did indeed have Pinkie Pie in it.